An absolute staple for me. It's my perfect YLBB colour that complements any lipstick, any gloss, anything! I think people have had a problem with WnW liners being too dry, but every time I buy them they're creamy and soft. I usually sharpen the outside layer when I buy a new one.
712 is a nude brown pink, the colour is more natural than MAC Spice, IMHO, not so orange. The price and quality are unbeatable, and it's amazing!
Great nude-pinky-brown that is very close to my natural lip colour. Quality is not the *best*, but it's decent and I'd rather splurge on other things anyway :) Random fact: did you know that name of this shade is Willow? I just found that out today.
This is a great lipliner. It is pretty close to spice and for .99 you can't ask for more.
Used this for years, goes with everything. Staple!
This is a reasonable facsimile of Spice and it is very creamy as well. I wear it with my MAC's Sheer Plum lipstick. They are perfect together!