UPDATE UPDATE: never mind. This flakes off everywhere even tightlining. Lol sorry! UPDATE: I have upped my rating from 2 to 4 because I have found a use for this! It is awesome for tightlining my upper lashline because it doesn't transfer to my waterline! It stays all day and does not smudge off! Although it smudges everywhere else, this is a great tightliner! OLD REVIEW: This product I have mixed emotions on. It is totally waterproof, but this smudges all of my eye lids and eye area like crazy! I would not buy again because although it's waterproof, it smudges insanely bad on me personally.

this is the first liquid liner i have tried. it's a lot harder to apply than pencil liner, but this stuff goes on really black and is definitely water proof! it took forever to apply right, hard to make thin lines, maybe i just need a better applicator tip. the bad part is that it's soooo difficult to get off and clumps like CRAZY around the eyelashes. but this is definitely a great value.

This liner was ok. It really did not last throughout the day. I really love the waterproof eyeliner I purchased at the dollar tree called L.A look. It was great. cheap and really worked.

Its an OK product. The applicator is alittle too thick for my small eyes. It isnt matte like the regular liquid liner.. it has a glossy finish. My problem is that it would flake off. It was ok but I prefer the regular eyeliner

Wow, what a great product!! I had been using Revlon Colorstay Liquid eyeliner for awhile, but I got tired of it fading. I was also annoyed with the large applicator tip-- I could never get a fine enough line.

This product has a tiny felt tip applicator, which is perfect for making a thin line along the upper lashline. It could also easily be built into a thicker line.. The product is very, very black. At first, I thought that this would be too liquidy, but it dries very quickly and does not run upon application. It also has amazing staying power (much better than Colorstay). This eyeliner makes my eyes look big, long-lashed, and well-defined. My eyes are on the smaller side, but I feel almost doe-eyed with the thin line from this on the outer 3/4 of my upper lashline.

(For those who have trouble getting it off-- I suggest looking around the product reviews for a better eye makeup remover. The problem is not the eyeliner!)

RUN to the store and buy this now!

Fairly Cheap, But Also low in quality.
the brush is sponge tip and very hard to work with, and the colors compared to to non waterproof collection are limited.

with use of a separate liner brush, it might be good.

This is the worst liquid eye liner I gave ever used! It doesn't last more then 5 hours and by that time it's smearing on my face. The worst part is that once this product dries it flakes, there's just no stopping it. I've used 2 different shades and even tried the waterproof formula, I thought it was worth trying because of the price, trust me, you don't need this crap in your collection.

I love this eyeliner when its actually on my lids and if I happened to somehow bypass my eyelashes in the process. HOwever that hardly never happens - if even the smallest amount gets on my lashes, they are instantly hardened and impossible to 'fix'. I also really dislike the applicator compared to the regular wet n wild liners. Will not repurchase

 I like how it looks in the end and it was definatley waterproof, long-lasting, and stayed put to my somewhat oily eyelids.
  I didn't have any trouble with the applicator tip like some other MUA users have found,  but it sometimes did clump my lashes and was hard to remove off of lashes.
 It indeed was hard to remove- even with a waterproof eye makeup remover. It took a couple go-overs/tries to remove it with my ordinary makeup remover. Although what I though was all gone- it wasn't. I know it had to be the eyeliner, as that was the only thing I've changed in my eye makeup. After removing, for the next couple days I'd find random black specks around my eyes. Best I could describe it..it was really annoying. I've never had that happen before.
I've learned that baby oil is another alternative to eye makeup remover- and it indeed worked with this eyeliner, though it does leave a bit of a greasy feeling. It removed ALL traces of it. No black specks this time. Nothing some water and pats with a towel can't fix. 
Overall, I'll save this when it's expected to rain later in my day, or to the amusment park (The rides you'd get soaked on)

I just bought this product as a substitute for my mac liquid last liner which is gona be discontinued:( But so far I love this product, and im kinda confused why there are so many bad reviews. I noticed the good reviews came from asian's with oily and non-existant lids, which I have, so im thinking this product will do well for me. Packaging isnt so good, but i dont care much about that. Some of the bad reviews are about not being able to take it off, but to me thats a great thing.