I've been using this product for about a year now, so I feel like I can write a good review about it. I don't have oily lids and am an avid gel/cream liner. I prefer cream/gel to all other eyeliner formulas. For comparison, I have used WnW and PF before this. Compared to WnW & PF, MAC is superior, however, I do not think it is the best out there. I am about halfway through my pot (although it's kind of hard to tell) and it is starting to dry out on me. I have "revived" it about 4 times now within the last month with contact solution. But the formula/application changes when you revive it each time. When it was new, it was wonderful. Application was smooth, staying power was amazing, and the color stayed true til the end of the day. But within less then a year, it has already started to dry. Now I have to use severa layers to get the intensity I want :( Overall, I think it is nice, but it is no means a HG product nor a great value. I will be trying Essence this as it $4 at Ulta for the same amount of product :) continued >>

My absolute favorite eye liner! It goes on smooth, and is super easy to apply with a brush. This gel liner gives you a more professional look as opposed to a pencil which can sometimes look “piecey” and messy. This liner stays put through the night & then some-not to mention the little jar lasted me months! continued >>

I LOVE this eyeliner. For a long time I was an e/l junky. I own most of the popular DS and HE brands of e/l but I never found exactly what I was looking for. Until this little loveliness in a jar. I now wear this every single day.

It doesn't smudge, move, migrate, etc. It dries matte.

I love that I can completely change the look of the eye makeup I'm wearing just by going with a heavy or thin line of this eyeliner. I seriously can't imagine ever using anything else again.

I love this so much. Its a really rich black, yet it dries right away and never smudges. It stays put for hours. I have had it for about 6 months, using it about 4 days out of the week and I still have most of it left and it is still as creamy as it was the day I bought it. This makes the price well worth it to me. It works really well with the slanted MAC eyeliner brush I bought. I wont ever buy any other eyeliner again.

This gel eyeliner is a GOD SEND. Sooo creamy and easy to work with plus is such an intense black that only makes the eyes standout even more. Plus a great investment, I have had mine since Oct 2011 and is still only half used and still creamy. Will last you a long time, if cap is secured after each use.

I love gel liner! Much more forgiving that liquid and a lot smoother than a pencil!

One of the best gel liners out there for me. It lasts all day on my super oily lids.
Very pigmented and is a nice consistency to work with.
Honestly, no complaints about this.

I only bought this gel liner once.I didnt like it.Its not even a really dark black(which I expect it) its a really soft black once you applied it.It dries up really quickly and irritates your eyes.Then it starts to crack up.Yikes! Im not buying this again.Im sticking to my wet n wild mega eyes gel cream liner. I think its much better despite the price but the eyeliner its really good.So yeah I wasnt satisfied with this product.

Best eyeliner ever, great consistency, super water/crease proof. and the price is pretty fair cmpared to other brands or eyeliner pencils.A small jar can run for a year at least.

Great gel eyeliner, but not necessarily better than any of the cheaper gel eyeliners I've bought. I'm yet to see something that sets it apart from the other ones, except it's price. Good product though.