I find the regular one with the curved brush is better than the waterproof one
I absolutely adore this mascara. I've experimented with a lot of (high end) mascara's and for the price of this one, well, you would think its pricier. I've been using it for a few years now and plan on continuing to do so.
This is probably my favorite drugstore mascara! When you first buy it it's an absolute nightmare of a mascara! It smudges, it's clumpy, it's just way to wet!! But after a week or so, the mascara will build itself up a bit and become a little more dry. Once it gets to that point, it's perfection! It gives nice volume, length, no flaking, and no smudging! It reminds me somewhat of the Make Up Forever Smoky Lash mascara! Which I also love! I would recommend this mascara! Especially to girls with long lashes looking for a bit more volume! :)
Simply my all time favourite mascara! Plus the price is ridiculous (in a good way) and can be found in any drugstore! I highly recommend it.
For some reason, this site won't let me give the 5/5 I wanted to. I love this in the Carbon Black. I did read other people's issues about the smudging, and I never use mascara on my bottom lashes because I have such sensitive skin and eyes. But this gives me fuller, darker lashes that don't look fake or tacky. I do not use the waterproof, just the original formula in this Carbon Black shade with the straight brush. Great product, great price. The one I keep coming back to.
Use only if its waterproof coz it smudges like crazy! Definitely a great product if you wanna amp the volume of your lashes.
Decent mascara. Added great volume but I also need length as well. So I wouldn't wear this on its own. No smudging, or flaking (although I never have that problem). I would purchase again if I caught it I sale.
I have this in waterproof, and I think it's an okay product. Gives very natural looking results, with some volume and a little length. the only downfall is that it doesnt hold a curl veyr well, like within 3 hours my lashes fall down and are no longer curled. It also smudges quite a lot on my bottom eye area. its very inexpensive though, so if this works for you then good for you
I returned this. After reading the reviews, I couldn't wait to try it out. I have delicate sparse lashes and small eyes. This just looked ridiculous. I could literally see this thick coating on my lashes and it did not hold a curl. Just too heavy for me. I do however LOVE the water-proof millions of lashes by L'oreal. Try it instead.
I have read various reviews, and I have my opinion regarding this mascara smudging or not being very water resistant. I live in Florida, where humidity and heat can be a REAL issue. After experimenting, because I like the look of this mascara, I have found this formula to work very effectively. Use this mascara in the regular formula, give it about 1 minute to set. Then apply a second coat with the waterproof formula. This prevents the mascara from running, but since you have put the regular non-waterproof on first, you do not need a eye makeup remover for waterproof eye makeup. Yes, I understand this means two tubes of mascara, plus two times the expense, but I have found this to work very well.