For someone with sparse, short, stick-straight lashes, I can't help but have high standards for mascara. I was bored over the weekend and decided to play with EVERYTHING in MAC.

For a MAC mascara, this really surprised me. The SA taught me to put on a coat, let it dry for a few seconds, then apply a second coat. Pretty darn good results; lengthened and voluminous lashes. However, my number one priority and requirement is that my mascara HOLDS CURL. This mascara, like other non-waterproof counterparts, fail to hold the curl to my lashes as they droop upon application.

It's really not a bad mascara and I'm sure it would work for those who have longer and more abundance of lashes. I'm just still on my hunt to find my HG mascara...

i absolutely love this mascara. it's similar (and better!) than diorshow. it goes on nice and thick and lasts ALL DAY and night. for only $13, this is a great deal.

I actually really like this mascara, which is rare because I usually HATE MAC mascaras. This is very comparable to my holy grail Dior Diorshow mascara. The wand is very similar and so is the formula.

After hearing all the hype about this mascara i decided to give it a try even though MAC is not known for their mascaras and i had a bad experience with zoom lash. anyways, i thought that the brush was a little too large for my liking but i worked with it and the formula actually did do a good job of thickening, but not so much for lengthening. and after 3 days of using this mascara, i started to notice that when i go to wash it off at the end of the day my eyes were burning and realized it was the mascara flaking off into my eye and causing it to burn. i never had this happen to me in my life until using this crap! and when i returned it, the lady at my MAC counter said the exact same thing happened to her. So, the moral of this story is that i will never buy mac mascaras ever again. i just dont know why people like this stuff. yuck.

Love, love, love this mascara! I've been looking for a dramatic mascara that stays put and this is it. It lengthens, curls, and adds tons of volume. It is second only to Diorshow, which is just too pricey to buy every month. This mascara is a keeper.

I love MAC mascaras. So when I knew this was going to come out, I knew I had to test it out for myself. It's a pretty good mascara. It's buildable and it coats my lashes beautifully, never clumping or flaking. Would definitely buy again.

I wasn't sure about the mascara when i first purchased it but the more i use it the more i like it. It is not like any I have used recently. It does not clump or stick for me like some people said. I start off with a thin first coat then apply a second. It curls my lashes beautifully, much more than any other mascara. It does not have the high drama of like a Dior Show, but it stays PUT. I do not get racoon eyes ever...even it the hot hot summer. I really like it and will continue to use it.

I really like this mascara...i might even love it. I have been using it every day since i got it. It can go on natural-looking, but i usually build it up. I have fairly long lashes as it is and this thickens and accentuates them nicelyThe formula doesn't dry too fast for me and i can apply some after it has dried and i don't get spider lashes. I have been looking for a good mascara and saw this on the mac website so i tried it. I did not know what to expect, but I am impressed and no more than 5 minutes ago, i just bought another tube of it haha...along with some russian red lipstick : ) (which i have never tried, but have heard things about on here)

When I heard this was a tubing mascara I wanted it. It is such a huge disappointment. Just, wow.

It might tube my lashes but I can't really tell because it goes on so clumpy and gross, I have yet to actually wear it. I wash it off and start over with Kiss Me every time.

Seriously, it's no better than a cheap and volumizing drugstore mascara.

I ordered this from Nordstrom shortly after its release due to all of the hype on Youtube. This mascara did not work for me. After two coats my lashes begin sticking together and I get the spider look, which is not cute. MAC Studio Fix mascara performs much better than this, so I will not repurchase.