I LOVE this concealer! LOVE LOVE LOVE! I was kinda on the fence about getting this, just because it's $18 and I didn't know if I would like it. The first time a got it, it was totally seperated, the oil and the color where like oil and water. So I took it back and got a new one, and this one didn't do that.

This doesn't break me out, even with the oil in it, lasts a very long time, and covers up my uneven skin tone. 4 stars :)

I'm sorry to say that I was quite disappointed with this. I love smashbox and been using the HD Foundation which is gr8 so had high hopes for this concealer. Unfortunately its not that good at concealing much at all. It is quite good for under the eye but dont think it covers very well. My skin breaks out every now and again and this concealer didnt seem to help at all. Its to watery I think. Very disappointed, especially as its quite expensive. Wont buy again.

Was looking for an HD concealer. Was a little pricy (22$ CAD) but decided it was the price to pay for something of quality. Let me tell you something. I used to buy the drugstore kind for half the price and it worked a lot better. The Smashbox one doesn't cover my dark circles, doesn't cover my blemishes. Like someone said, sometimes it is just oil and water that comes out of the tube, the product doesn't mix well at all. It creases around my eyes and it's annoying to have to fix it everytime. Plus, it's too yellow for my skin (I'm fair skinned), and a sales consultant at Sephora told me it was my skin tone. Not true!

I liked how this concealer didn't irritate my skin. However, I didn't like it under my eyes because it would crease in just a few minutes. I feel like it doesn't last as long either. The coverage is pretty good. I am looking for a better concealer than this but for now, I'm going to stick with it.

i love love love this product ... it covers great goes on great and last long time ... to help blend the product i use a consealer bursh and i DO NOT RUB it in .. i pat and that helps get the color in the tiny places (if need be) and i noticed pating it help keep the color in one place u no unlike when u rub it moves it around to the place u really dont want the color to go and it with using the brush it gets my eye area very very well ... i love this stuff and i will buy again and again

I bought this concealer a while back and I've loved it ever since I got it. I have very dark circles and I've been on the look out for my holy grail concealer for a while now. This concealer comes pretty darn close to what I want. It brightens up my eye area without settling into the fine lines under my eyes and really makes a huge difference on my whole face. A little goes a VERY long way. One tiny little squeeze gives me enough product to conceal my bags and blemishes. Also the applicator is unique. The tip is in a slanted angle which makes it easy to blend the concealer underneath your eyes. I literally have no cons for this product other than the price, but it is worth it considering how long it lasts you. I would absolutely repurchase.

I'm surprised this gets so many complaints, I really like this product! I think this product covers up my dark circles pretty well, and it stays on for hours. I like that it's thin, so I can build it up to the amount of coverage I need for the day. Also, it blends well, so it's easy for me to work with when I'm running late and only have a few minutes for makeup.

this was recommended to me by a SA at Sephora because my skin is so fair its hard to find a good concealer. I really like this. I can use this for both under eye and covering blemishes. Its not cakey or watery and thats why for me its perfect for both. Medium coverage, neutral toned, doesn't settle into find lines. I will repurchase even though its a little on the pricey side for me.
Edit: I changed mine to 5 stars instead of 3 because after more uses I discovered its even better then expected.

This is a great concealer if you are lazy...sorry, time deficient...like me and don't want to use two different products for concealing under eyes and blemishes. It's that perfect in-between texture that doesn't look too thick/dry under the eyes, yet has enough consistency to "disappear" spots. I haven't had 100% satisfaction with Smashbox products, but would definitely buy this one again.

Worst cosmetic product of my life. I don't use a lot of face makeup and even I knew it was working terribly. It did not help any of my under eye bags or darkness. In fact, it only made under my eyes darker and called my attention to lines that I was not even previously aware of. I took this product back immediately after two disappointing uses.