My HG mascara. Never flakes or rubs off.

For me, the blacker the mascara the better, so I was always torn between Diorshow Waterproof and Diorshow Blackout, when this came out I was like "finally!" But I don't love it. It's good but the brush on the original Diorshow Waterproof is much better and I feel like the formula is better too: smoother and more volumizing. Sure this is better than probably almost every mascara out there, but just not the original waterproof.

I got a free sample of this mascara from Sephora and I have to say it's really good stuff. The brush is HUGE, but it does a great job at coating all of your lashes. The only drawback is that it makes clean application a bit challenging. My lashes looked really thick and long, definitely great for going out, but also appropriate for everyday. Though I love this mascara, I can't justify paying for anything other than drugstore brands when, in my opinion, there are some out there that are just as good. However, I do hope Sephora keeps it in the sample rotation!

I bought this to take on holiday with me so I could wear it in the sea or the pool. I wore it on the day I flew out and by the time I got to the airport it was all underneath my eyes. It was a complete mess. This happened everytime I wore it without getting near any water. Weird thing was after just wearing it for an hour it would somehow come off underneath my eyes, but when I used make up remover it wouldn't budge. It did give my eyes a nice dramatic effect, but that was the only positive thing I can say about it.

Thick, black-black lashes. I love the rock and roll look I get with this product. I've been using this product for years and love the dark color it makes my lashes. I could use without the clumping and the fact that it is so hard to get off at night. Nevertheless, it is a dramatic look that I love.

Expensive - but IMO - worth it. VERY darkening and builds good, long lashes. I like this product better than many other masacaras.

It is an OK mascara. It is not fantastic, I love the YSL faux cils much more. It clumps a bit and does not make my lashes look dramatic. I will not repurchase, but have no problem using up this tube.

This mascara is the perfect inky black color but it smudges like crazy! I had much higher expecations for the price I paid. I will stick to Maybelline Full 'N' Soft.

This mascara is inky blackest black, applies well, hold curl ALL day. It is also flakes and smudges underneath the eyes (and this is only when it is applied to my upper lashes) and is a NASA mission to remove at night with a targeted dual-action oil-based eye make-up remover. My conclusion? There are better mascaras out there. Spend your cash wisely.

I love this stuff! It's dark and goes on kind of wet. It definitely stays put too. I wash my face, use cold cream on my eye make and still have smudges of it in the morning. It doesn't smudge too bad for me during the day and is perfect for every day use.