I am disappointed with this liner. I own the black shade and I need 2 coats to get a solid black color, otherwise it comes out gray. Secondly it smudges and wears away soon after applying. Maybe I need to use a sealer afterwards? I assumed that 'colorstay' meant it stays put.
This is one of the best kohl eyeliners I've used! I can't verify the 16-hour staying power, but I can say that this eyeliner has withstood extreme humidity+heat. The only downside is that if you line your bottom eyelids, it may smudge a little by the end of the day. I love the little sharpener at the end of the pencil. I considered this 'dirt cheap' because usually you can find a double-pack at Wal-Mart or Target for $6-7, or if you check your weekly circular for CVS/Walgreen's/Rite Aid, you can often find it for a Buy1Get1Free deal.
What I liked about this liner was that it was highly pigmented and a nice deep black color. Also, it applied very smoothly. Unfortunately, I don't buy into the whole "colorstay" deal - within an hour of applying I had raccoon eyes! There are other eyeliners out there that work better for a lower price, so I doubt I will repurchase.
to be honest, I want to love this eyeliner so much, cos it is cheap, widely available and really stay on my waterline, BUT it gives me blurred vision whenever I apply it on my waterline :( so sad! I will stick to my equally effective but much more expensive MUFE aqua pencil then.
I started with this eyeliner 3 years ago since I was looking for a liner that doesn't require to sharp and revlon to me guarantees a good quality. I love it, it's smooth, stays all day/night. The presentation is very useful since is rollover. Love it. It's the only black eyeliner I use and will definitely buy it again.
This product still smudges on me all the time and the staying power is not impressive. I don't think it's as pigmented as other eyeliners out there. I am pretty disappointed considering the rave reviews. I'm sure it's a great product for some, but for me it just didn't cut it.
This is my HG eyeliner! My old brand smudged and racoon'd like nobody's business, so I picked this up because of the promising reviews and it really is amazing. I have it in both black and brown; they're both very rich and extremely pigmented. It pulls a little, but if you use the neat little sharpener at the bottom of the pencil it fixes it.
This stuff has the best lasting power; even after P.E. in the morning at school (I'm one of those people who can't go ANYWHERE without something on their face) I don't need to reapply it, save for some touching up on the corners. The only downside is that it is tricky to get off. Even when I use special eye makeup remover, I still have to scrub and scrub to get rid of this sucker. Overall, I HIGHLY recommend it to anyone, and I will be repurchasing again and again.
The best eyeliner ever. Kind of expensive for a drugstore brand,but it is worth the money. I have oily eyelids, but after applying MAC Prep+Prime Eyebase and some shadow this liner stays put for hours and hours and hours!!! It doesn't smudge, it doesn't loose its color through out the day, it is just amazing!!! I will keep buying it for as long as they make it. A+++++
I LOVE this eyeliner. Its the one i've been using for quite some time. I love how it lasts throughout the day with a maximum of maybe one touch up. The actual product lasts a long time, I've had it for a couple months now. Would definitely recommend and already have!
This is an excellent black liner. I've tried MUFE aqua eyes, UD 24/7 liner pencils, Mac powerpoint in engraved and Mac feline Kohl power and they stillsmudge on me. it helps to set it with eyeshadow, but it's still an extra step that i don't necessarily mind, but it would be nice to not have to do it.
well, ive had the best results with this liner pencil.
I can skip the setting it with eyeshadow step, and it still stays very well on my lash line. i have yet to really test it out on my waterline.... but all in all, this really a good product. definitely worth checking out.