These shimmer eye pencils are new to E.L.F.'s line so I picked up 3 of them, Twinkle Teal, Black Bandit & Plum Passion. They're only $1 each so I figured it was worth it to see if they were worth a flip. They're surprisingly good! They have small flecks of silvery shimmer throughout the product so I was worried that it would pull or tug, or maybe that the liner would be dry & crusty but it's not. The liner is very smooth & creamy and applies nicely. In fact, it's a bit too creamy and smudgy so you may want to top it off with some matching shadow to seal it. It stays put on me for a good 6 hours or so and then starts to wear off a bit at the day's end. For $1 it 's a pretty good deal.