Ever since getting hooked on eyeliner and using a specific skill called "tightlining", I do not crave for the eyeliner look at all because the tightlining provides the natural, fuller lash look without the seeing the eyeliner at all. But buying this one sale, I use it based on the basic eyeliner technique and it's for those days when I want to look more primped out than usual, and it does not disappoint. The smudging is to a minimal but it does not budge provided I use Urban Decay's Eye Primer Potion, and it keeps it looking sharp and flawless. This is one of the only drugstore gel eyeliners out there, and I like it so far until a better one comes along!

I love this eyeliner. This is the easiest to apply eyeliner ever and is also the blackest. This is a must have.

I've had one for like 3 months, and it totally has lasted me! I've only tried blackest black since that's the color eyeliner I pretty much ever use. I really like this product, it's pretty great quality, it lasts and easy to apply. It also has great availability because you can buy it in a whole lot of places. The only con for me is how hard it makes your brushes D:

this stuff lasts for a good amount of time on the waterline , it doesnt irratate my eyes & has a lot of colors . i have 3 of them (:

I have decided that gel/cream liners just don't work for me. I have tried this Maybelline gel liner, L'Oreal HIP's, Wet N' Wild's, and Physicians Formula, and they all smudge like crazy on me. And with how pigmented this is, it gives the worst panda eyes ever. I have oily, hooded lids. so that's probably why, but I just find pencil liners last a lot longer on me without smudging, so will be sticking to those. I did like the brush this came with and the nice dark winged out line I could get. And it went easily onto the waterline, but just did not last for more than an hour before transferring.

This is fantastic! I have had it for 6 or 7 months, wear it 4 or 5 times a week, and over half is left! It lasts well without flaking, peeling or smudging, I've even worn it swimming. The brush included is pretty good too. It's my favourite eye liner and at only 10 dollars it's worth it :)

This is a decent liner. I like the sort of matte sparkle it has built in. It's not the black-black that I usually go for, but I like that it's different. It's great for applying to top lashes with a wing. I'm not so good at putting it on bottom lashes. Hard not to poke yourself. Still, it's nice and creamy,and easy to wash off at the end of the day. Buy this.

I love love love this gel eyeliner. I have had this for about 6 months and it still feels the same - it hasn't dried out. I have tried many gel eyeliners - bobbi brown, mac, coastal scents, etc. but I think this the THE BEST out of all....

Generally, this does it's job. I've always used Bobbi Brown's Gel Liners and I've never gone to anything else. I gave this a try and was seriously disappointed. The formula is a bit too dry for my taste, it seriously irritated my eyes, and it smudged a TON during the duration of the day. I would not recommend this product. I'd rather use BB's liner over this 100 times over.

I LOVE THIS EYELINER!!! This eyeliner is so easy to work with! It was my first Gel liner and I will by tons more if they are all like this. It is creamy, but doesn't smudge too much, but you can if you try. The brush it came with is okay, not the best. The only thing I don't like about the pacageing is the white thing in the lid falls out sometimes, but not that much! I love this liner!