=/ i had really high expectations for this liner. i bought it twice and returned it twice. at first i loved loved the creaminess of this liner. it glided on my eyes like butter, no tugging at all. but it smudged like crazy =( too bad.
I heard a lot of good reviews for this product and so I decided to try it. As i bought it in a sale, it wasnt too expensive. The reviews had said that this eyeliner does not smudge and will stay put '24-7'. Obviously, this was an exaggeration but I didnt realise how much of exaggeration it was. This eyeliner smudges like crazy and i was really dissapointed. However, the colour was very rich and application was pretty smooth, although i do not think i will find myself buying the product again.
Really happy with this eyeliner. It stays on well and goes on easily. It works well for the inner rim too if you like to do that sort of thing.
This worked great at first, but I wouldn't purchase it again because it does smudge and it's not any better than the cheaper drugstore ones.
This eyeliner for me, was a waste of $$.
Doesnt stay on my waterline.
Application is VERY soft
Spent more time sharpening the pencil then using it
Smudges after application (perhaps if you are looking for a smokey eye look/smudged eyeliner then this liner would be great for that)
Would NOT repurchase again
love love love this, this is def my holy grail eye liner. Creamy, buttery glides right on without the need for stretching and tugging. dark pigmentation and can be blended quite easily if you do so pretty quickly after application as it kind of sets. good top that doesnt get lost and come off as well- one of my hates when the tops fall off and the tip gets ruined.
I'm a big fan of Urban Decay products, and after hearing raves for this liner(it's so black! it stays so well on the waterline!), I fully expected to love it ..but I don't. It's a nice deep black, and it's super creamy, but it seems like the creaminess is actually the problem that I have with it. One stroke isn't opaque enough, and if I go over it again, it's like it erases itself because it smudges away, so I'm stuck trying to go back over the light spots and fill them in. I've had much better luck with the Sephora and Ulta brand eyeliners as well as some drugstore brands.
I'm not sure what is wrong. I read reviews with people saying it lasts so long especially on their waterline but that's not the case with me.
I do love how smooth it glides on and the creamy texture but it doesn't last at all for me. I put on my waterline and and just seriously a few minutes later its already smudging everywhere under my eye and looks really messy. If I use it on my top lashline then I get a big line in my crease which is not a good look. The only time I use this is sometimes as a base before I put my liquid eyeliner on.
I ve tryed so many liners its hard to find one that lasts on the waterline for more than a hour !
This one was ok less smudgy and meesy than other ive tryed it had ok lasting power , i will still be on the lookout for a better one.
This eyeliner is so smooth and creamy. It goes on really opaque. But it's pretty hard to smudge for a smokey eyes.