This product lasts all day, and even over night if you wanted it to! Definitely my number one eyeliner, and I've tried many! This beats the super-good Maybelline unstoppable eyeliner!
PROS: long-lasting, really black, easy to sharpen, comes off well w/remover
CONS: needs sharpener a lot because the tip dries out fast, not the best for smokey-eye blending, not creamy enough (but still pretty-dang good!)
Hmm i like this actually. First time buying urban decay eyeliner and i try zero. and compared with my cheap drugstore eyeliners like prestige eyeliner in black, this UD zero stays put much better. there is slight smudging which is why i give the product 4 lippies but it is waterproof like it says and it will stay put unlike other eyeliners that just fade off into the air and looks like i didnt apply anything. i love this! :)
Im not too impressed w/ this particular liner. It is soft but its similar to my Morbid Makeup black liner which i can also use for my lips. MM is also way cheaper ($1.99).
this color sucks! i liked 1999 & it stayed well but this color smudged & smudged & smudged some more! will not repurchase this color,ill stick w/ my ColorStay thank you. taking off lippies
This eyeliner is amazing. It glides on smoother than any other liners I have tried. It is so easy to apply and so creamy. The color is a rich black. I can create a natural look for daytime or smudge it out for a smoky look at night. I use it every day. It is a staple for me!
EDIT: I have switched to Ulta automatic eyeliner in black. It is a darker black and stays on longer. Plus I got it on sale for a dollar!
I bought the 24/7 eyeliner in Zero with the Urban Decay Hall of Fame set back in October, and I used the eye pencil obsessively in the weeks that followed purchasing it. Altogether it was pretty good - it went on smoothly and altering the thickness of the line was super easy. The colour was a bit of a letdown - I've seen YouTube gurus and reviewers on here rave about how 'true black' in colour it is, but I wouldn't agree - it went on a kind of shiny sheer black-grey and took a couple of layers to make the colour build up.
However, the one huge problem I have with this eyeliner is sharpeningit. I don't know if thsi is just peculiar to me but I found because the liner was so soft that it broke easily when sharpening, the wood incasing the product splintered so when I tried to apply it to my waterline the splinters grabbed and scratched at my eyeskin. Ouch. Generally didn't have too great an experience with this product. I may try a different colour to compare but until then, thumbs down for this one.
This is great, goes on smoothly . But its not good for bringing the line out and tilting it up at the outside of the upper lids. So I had to use something else to tilt the line up a bit. I'm still looking for the perfect eye liner pencil. But I prefer this over the others Ive used for the ease of use and true black color. I got it at Sephora. I hope it fits my sharpeners.
I bought a kit of samplers, so I got lots of colors, and this was in it. I like the intensity of this line of eyeliners, but they are very soft, so they don't hold shape well. If you drop one on the point, like I did, forget using it again because it gets smooshed and becomes a little pancake that you can use to draw anything other than dots. They are a bit smudgy. I like them anyway, and do use them regularly. I wouldn't pay 17 bucks for one of them, but when the sets come out with a few smaller sizes in different colors, it's worth buying then.
I recently purchased this eyeliner and it sure does glide on easily; however, I was not too satisfied with it. The eyeliner does not stay on the water line after a while. I tend to have to reapply it several times throughout the day. I should have tested the eyeliner before purchasing it (especially since the price is $17 dollars before tax).
This pencil is amazing for creating the smudgy eyeliner look I love! It stays on all night even if I go out clubbing and keeps its colour true. It might not be the best for a clean line but for everything else it is amazing
This was just ok. I don't see the hype. It looks great on, and it applied very easily. However, I saw smudges, which i very much dislike. I used it for my lids, it worked really well. No creases or anything. I didn't budge. However, I purchased this eyeliner for my waterline. And it didn't stay and it smudged. And since it is sooo dark, it was kind of noticable. For the cost, I wouldn't purchase again. I feel like I can get other eyeliners for cheaper and have the same effect. I think one thing the can do to improve on this product is maybe having a sponge applicator at the end in order to smudge the liner because the texture is so creamy that it can easily move if not applied lightly.