I like this product because it glides on so easily and very precise when used with the brush. I started using it for my upper and lower lash lines and the upper one stayed while the lower one smudged. I did not put it on my waterline but underneath it and I also set it with some black eyeliner--but there was a lot of smudging going on.
I think I'm going to stick with the Maybelline Line Stiletto liquid eyeliner and will not repurchase this product again.

for me, this liner is just okay. it dried out on me FAST. and the brush that comes with it is worthless, IMO, unless you want to look like amy winehouse. when compared to black track fluidline by MAC, this is a pretty decent alternative, but unfortunately, not something i would buy again. MAC wins this round.

I Really like this product. I had a different gel liner before but it has been a while. So, I was hesitant to pay the price for a product that dries out so quickly. I recommend this product to anyone that uses more than just gel liners. This product will sit and wait for you.
The only thing that I dont care for is if you use the brush included and you dont clean them after use the liner can get on your other brushes or brush container.

omg HG product alert..
got this the other day and am in love.. this is the best gel liner ive ever got.. better than mac fluidline and bobbi brown..and so cheap..
buy it now..

for the girl who is the beginner have tried a lottttttttttts of eyeliner like me .. finally found something that REALLY WORK best. Thanks Maybelline!

Works well. Don't leave the top off for an extended period of time, though - it seems to dry out quickly.

This is my first time using a gel eyeliner and I LOVE it! I usually use Maybelline's liquid liner, but I saw this one at the store and decided to give it a try.

I love the colour (got the Brown, my usual liner colour) and the little glass jar (although it MAY become a bit of a hassle when I'm in a rush). The product went on smoothly and the "wing" looked way more natural than when I did it with a liquid liner (which just looked like I used a marker!).

My only concern is with the packaging, as it is an open jar and I'll be dipping the brush into it every time I use it. It says to simply wipe the brush with paper towel after each use, but can I clean it with some baby shampoo instead and still not lose the shape of the brush???

Overall, I'm quite happy with the product. I'll just have to start using eye makeup remover again, rather than just soap and water :S

I am religious about using my bobbi brown gel eyeliner and bought this on a whim if im honest. I LOVE this,i rarely buy drugstore products but this is amazing,goes on very smooth and great pigmentation with it. I swatched it against my bobbi brown,my BB is a little darker but i can deal with that to save around £10. this will now be my HG gel eyeliner.

I am a newbie at using gel liners. This is the second brand I have tried. I liked the quality of the product and the brush. It certainly has staying power and is very difficult to remove. I had to cleanse, then use eye makeup remover twice to finally get all traces of this off last night. Afterwards my eyes were very irritated--not sure if it was the eyeliner or all the cleansing (my regular foaming cleanser and Vital Lash by Physician's Formula for eye makeup removal.) Today at work I look like Bob Marley--red eye to the max. For gel liner, I will stick with my Pixi which applied nicely, wore like iron but removed easily. This stuff is for someone who wants a 24-hour liner that won't budge. I may use again for a special night out but not for everyday.

this is my go to liner for upper eyelids. i love everything about it. it slides on perfectly on my lids and i thought i wouldn't like the brush it came with very much. But i was wrong, i love it too. some people say there's not much in the jar, but for a gel liner, i think there is more then enough. i will defiantly be repurchasing.