I heard that this mascara is a love or hate mascara and I wanted to try it. The first time i tried it i honestly hated it. The formula is too wet and sticky, it also clumps to easily. When i first tried it i legit had like 5 lashes because it was so clumpy.

This stuff gets a bad rap. It's good! Get it.

Cute and packaging, formula not so good. It is soo runny, and it smudges throughout the day! My lashes look nice, but they dont hold the curls very well. (I have straight asian lashes).

I'm a bit surprised at the low rating for this! While it doesn't provide tons of volume, it lengthens my lashes like no other and they are completely separated and black black black.I personally have this in noir black. It is a pretty wet formula, but I tend to have better results with those. My lashes also feel soft after this dries, unlike some mascaras that lengthen so much - they feel dry and I can...feel them when I blink. Drives me nuts! This doesn't do that. I can see why someone that wasn't very dramatic lashes might not enjoy this, but I still reach for it. For me, it's great for layering under a volumizing one if I want drama. I personally don't experience clumps and flaking or anything. Guess I'm lucky!

I also like the small brush - I find it SO hard to get my outer & inner lashes with the brushes most mascaras have today, they're huge. This is the perfect size for those little lashes and it makes my lashes look so good since they're all completely covered.

Does not layer well and has a tendency to clump. This has a very wet formula and is easily smudged. It does darken lighter lashes but does not lengthen them in any way.

I used to use this mascara when I was a teen. I think it must have been a better product then. This time, I purchased this mascara due to it being on sale. I am very disappointed. I think both the product and the brush are at fault. I was not able to build up a nice, unclumpy coverage. Nor could I easily lengthen or curl my lashes with the mascara. After working on layering the product on my lashes, I took a look and was horrified to see that like another reviewer, my lashes resembled Tammy Fay. So I washed my face and went out without makeup. I will try using one of my other mascaras and this in combo just to use it up since I bought three on sale. Never again!

First of all, I really don't like the brush. It doesn't separate my lashes at all. It just clumps them and doesn't hardly make them longer. But my mom swears by it so I guess it just depends on the person. It's really cheap so it's worth a try.

Very nice everyday mascara. I own the Blackest Black/Washable one

Awful.wet and burn like pure poison!is a classic? You better be modern then.awful

I too once loved this mascara, but the recipe has changed! While the formula is able to be layered, I always look like Tammy Faye Baker afterward. I am sad to say the old familiar pink and green mascara will no longer be welcomed here.