I bought this mascara yesterday, the girl in Mac said it was much better than their new False Lash mascara, when I got home and tested it out, it was only OK! I was really looking forward to writing something positive about it. The packaging is so cute though! Also this product does not have 2 brushes, if you unscrew the pink part and the purple you can see that the stopper from the pink is much smaller so therefore you get less product, when you unscrew the purple part you get more on the brush for the intense look. I just feel for €23.50, I could have got a much better mascara, I still love it but kinda disappointed after it'd been recommended to me. :)
I love this mascara, it doesnt flake, curls lashes, the pink side gives a longer natural effect and the purple gives curl and dramatic volume...sure i will buy again!
Oh I Love this mascara! It's amazing and it makes your lashes long and perfect! One of the best mascaras out there if you ask me :)
I got this mascara for Christmas after wanting it for a while. I LOVE IT! I have never liked a MAC mascara so much! It does everything that I want in a mascara and stays well, especially when I curl it. I will be repurchasing when I run out. My HG mascara!! Never thought I would say that coming from MAC
I've been on the hunt for a good mascara & I must say this is my favorite! It's truly amazing!! It made my eyelashes look full, long & held the curl!! I don't have neither long nor a lot of eyelashes. But this mascara made it look like I had fake lashes on! Even my boyfriend noticed the difference!! This mascara is waayyy BETTER than Dior's blackout which USE to be my fav.
Okay I have been using this daily for three weeks so I can give a decent review. I am going on record and screaming this is THE BEST MASCARA I HAVE EVER EVER USED! I have natural curled lashes but they lack volume and length in my opinion, and this does both. I use the naughty side one full coat then another coat sharing between the eyes then finally a coat of the haute side. My lashes have volume and length I am elated at this product. I haven't been impressed with previous MAC mascara, and was using Maybelline Falsies before thus, as long as they make this I will buy it!
Update October 31, 2013 two years and still going strong!!
love this mascara. I ve tried mostly all the mac brand mascaras and this is one of the top three.
I have largely avoided mascaras for years now and only used them on a very rare basis. No matter what techniques I tried, the mascara would look thick and heavy and clumpy on my thin and short eyelashes. So when I purchased this mascara, I didn't have my hopes to high, though I was excited to give it a try based on reviews I read here. I am completely floored at the total awesomeness of this mascara! It makes my lashes look FIN-TASTIC! It gives definition and bit of depth due to the color but still looks rather natural (though I am sure it's obvious to others I'm wearing mascara, it's a very minimal look which is right up my alley!)
YAY! for this mascara, my HOLY GRAIL mascara product!
Looking at other reviews makes me wonder if I maybe got a damaged product. This mascara was too liquid. It takes about a minute to dry and it is very difficult to work with. At the end of a 4 coat application I get length but no volume or curl. This mascara was about $18 in Canada, and although cheap for MAC, I think you can get better mascaras for the same price.
I have been on a long hunt for the perfect mascara. I really like the dramatic look and love mascaras with alot of black pigment. I usually go for the ones with Extreme Black, etc. This mascara is exactly what I have been looking for. I don't use the pink natural wand. I only use the purple, dramatic one. The pink one is good for separating after you have already put most of it on. I would definitely repurchase. I am in love!