everytime i wear this product it leaves a terrible smudge underneath my eye, i come home from school looking like a raccoon unless i bring cotton swabs with me. i also left the cap off for about an hour and the product dried out and applies poorly

OMG! This pencil is so amazing I love it! It is dark, stays put, and easy to apply!! I love it better than my MUFE aqua eyes. I have a thing for very black eyeliners and this is the best one out there!!! Plus it has a smudger at the end!!! Beware you need a good sharpener though.

I will not buy this again because I think I'm allergic to it. This stuff burns my eyes something horrible! It applies smoothly with a beautiful dark black finish which I like. I had to remove this from my eyes while at work because I couldn't take my eyes watering and the constant itching it caused. FYI I'm not a contact lens wearer.

This product is NOT for contact lens wearers!

I gave this liner two chances and BOTH times it smeared into my eyes and forced me to remove my contacts and wear my glasses. It also irritated my eyes.

I would not buy this again due to the fact that I cannot use it while I wear my contacts and I wear my contacts every day.

Okay, So I am 16 and I just statrted wearing this stuff and it comes on great and easy and nice but by the time i'm done with school some it has come off and It's annoying any ideas but I do truly like this product alot!

This eyeliner is a staple in my makeup collection. I always seem to find that it's sold out in my local Wal-Mart and drug stores. It goes on smooth and lasts all day. It doesn't smudge or end up halfway down my cheek. Which is a plus. The pencil is easy to sharpen as well.

I absolutley adore this product and I swear by it. I am always on the search for the darkest and most intense eyeliner. \i prefer to use actual liquid liner on the top lip but this works better than anyothe rpencilfor the top lid. I never have a problem with any eyeliner smudging so I cannot comment on wether this one will smudge or not. I own many mac eyeliners and even the urban decay 24 hr and I think if you are looking fo rth emost intense and blackest liner...I would reccomend this one...and this is coming from someone who is willing to spend up to $30 on a good pencil liner. This liner also blends very well...i would reccomend this for more of a night out look.

After using gel eyeliners for the last five years, i've been on the hunt for a good pencil eyeliner. This eyeliner comes in a deep inky black, it glides on smoothly, and I can apply eyeshadow over it and blend for a smoky eye. I was hoping this would be comparable to Urban Decay's 24/7 eyeliners, but it has a little more slip and smudges easily, and stings when it gets into my eyes. Overall, I still prefer the Urban Decay liner over this.

I love this eyeliner! My lids are pretty oily, and eyeliners tend to crease and transfer on my eyes after a few hours. This stuff lasts and lasts! I have the eyeliner in grey, but it comes out very pigmented (pretty much black) I would compare this to UD 24/7 Zero. Two cons:

- Requires frequent sharpening
- Hard to smudge (making it not very forgiving)

Nevertheless, I would recommend this eyeliner to anyone :)

Amazing eyeliner!! I thought i was never going to find anything better than my revlon colorstay liner, but this one definitely is much more intense. it applies so smooth and not waxy at all, i'm very impressed. stays on the waterline, which is what i mainly look for in an eyeliner. not so happy that is a pencil instead of mechanical, but for the color payoff, i'll deal.