Was really excited to get this after all the comments but I'm very sad that its not working great for me :( Despite having monolids and the tiniest of folds in my eyelids, this thing creased like mad on me! Just testing it out whilst sitting in front of the computer browsing the internet, this creased to almost nothing in about 2 hours! I don't understand! I don't have oily eyelids by any standards and I've never ever had an eye product (and I use a lot believe me) crease on before :( even tried it with primer, on bare skin... over eyeshadow etc. nothing worked :( So very sad. The packaging and ease of use and pigmentation of this thing is amazing though! So lucky for you people that can get it to stay on :)

I own this product in black and brown. The brown eyeliner is rarely used, but the black color is pretty darn amazing! It is very pigmented, easy to use and long wearing. I reach for this over my revlon colorstay, milani and wet n wild eyeliners. It is a fantastic product at a fantastic price!

I got this along with the mascara two weeks ago. Honestly not my favorite. When it goes on its really dark and nice black. The tips is a fealt tip and nice shape. Now for the "but" everyone's waiting for. It smudges so bad on me! If it smudges on me while awaiting for it to dry, I have to go over it with so much makeup remover. I tried water, clinique, Chanel, and nuetragena remover and only the clinique took it of a little better, but I could still see a little black smudge. I think I'll stick to my Pycisians Formula liner because the brush is so much better and its easier to remove. Oops almost forgot about the packaging! It's alright. I like how the cap clicks but its really hard to put on and take off. I keep hitting the tip every time I open and close it. Oh well I guess ill use it up and most likely won't repurchase.

I got this in brown, and it sucked so much. Too dry, barely showed up on my eyes, did not apply smoothly, and left a pink stain later. Awful!

Don't hate me for saying this but I didn't like this product because it smeared & smudged all over. It's not even the tiniest bit water resistant much less waterproof. I think the packaging is really good because the cap clicks on very tight so I suspect it is less susceptible to drying out. I also think it's super affordable, very easy to apply & pigmented enough (not a lot but I'd say medium). My major problem is that it doesn't last & not only that, it smudges like watercolor paint. Sorry, but it's a no go for me. continued >>

It faded like a crack addicts hair.

HG. Forget the MAC Penultimate and the Lancome Artliner thingy, ladies and gents if you want a good pen eyeliner that dosen't skip, goes on black and stays black look no further. This little sucker is wonderful and it's 2.00 freakin dollars!!!! Can you say definite repurchase? As long as I live!!!

I had this in black. At first I really loved it. The tip was easy to work with, goes on smooth even with my unsteady hand. But the color wasn't black enough sometimes I had to put another black liquid eyeliner on top of it. It got dried out after second week I used it. The main reason I won't buy it anymore..

Figured I'd try this since I like Jordana mascara. For the price, this eyeliner is wonderful... fairly easy to apply, good staying power, doesn't smudge easily, doesn't burn or itch. BUT the packaging is cheap... specifically the cap. I don't know if I got a bad one or what, but every time I go to pull it off it sticks and I end up getting black hands. So I'm deducting a lippie for my troubles and won't repurchase.

I love this stuff. The smell doesn't bother me and it stays on for the whole day. Doesn't smudge or anything and I tend to have oily lids. The tip is sturdy but soft (felty) at the same time. It draws lines wonderfully. I'm about to buy 5 more of these.