My HG eyeliner. Highly pigmented, and quite budge-proof. The super-sharp tip (as per its name) makes lining my eyes a breeze. My first liquid eyeliner was with Maybelline and it was terrible, especially the brush. I stock up on Kate whenever I visit Japan.
I'm very new to using eyeliners. Just starting trying out for over a month. In fact, I only use pencil liners. After hearing all the raves of this product, I decided to give it a try. It's really a very good eyeliner. I have oily eyelids and my eyeshadow will crease on my eyelids by the afternoon. However, this eyeliner didn't smudge a bit even till I get home after work.
It is truly SUPER SHARP! I don't have a very steady hand but I have no problem drawing a fine line using this eyeliner =) It's really very good value for money.
This is my HG liquid eyeliner! My very first liquid eyeliner was some Maybelline one, and it was **terrible** trying to get an even line - the tip was too soft and uncontrollable, and I practically gave up on liquid eyeliners for some time. This KATE one is just perfect, almost fool-proof, for a controlled, precise application. The color I use is black, which is nice and dark, though not quite as rich/intense as I would hope. This was about US$10 in Japan, and readily found at almost any drugstore. It's harder to find in Hong Kong, though. This eyeliner is much better than KATE's other eyeliner - the quickliner, I think. That doesn't do as good a job - the tip is not as fine and precise as this one is. No smudging either - amazinggg! Love! A definite repurchase.
This is the best liquid eyeliner ! Can build on for intensity. I have it in brown, thinking to get the black one next, love the packaging and quality.
Love this liner. I was hesitant to buy it since a lot of reviewers said it wasn't black (I got the black one yes)- after much mental anguish, I finally sucked it up and bought it. In the store, I swatched it on my hand and it certainly didn't look dark black- however at home, on my eye- it was black. Not as dark as say, Mac Blacktrack Fluidline but certainly not light greyish black. I love it. The fine brush lets you draw a "Albion-type" fine line LOL (otherwise known as a super fine precise line) and the pen style gives you great control. I will definately purchase this again!!
sorry to mess up the perfect score. its everything like the other viewers mentioned. great liquid liner that dosent smudge, lasts all day, gives a natural thin line. colour isnt deep black but kinda looks grey on me. unfortunately i cant repurhcase this cos whenever i use this, my eyes swell! stupid eyes!! so if you arent sensitive, i highly recommend this if you are looking for a liner that is smudgeproof and cheap.
Amazing amazing amazing. Draws a perfect, thin line and lasts all day. It has an ink-like consistency. Agree, it could be a bit darker, but I'll take it. Strongly recommended.
this is a great eyeliner. it never smudges and lasts the whole day. you get a super thin line, which is great for the lower lashes and you can easily build up to a thicker line. i bought it at a drugstore and i think its only available in Asia. its the first eyeliner ive tried
This eye liner is the end of all liquid liners for me. I tried a couple of liquid liners before, but I could never make the neat, super thin line. This liner is very easy to use. The tip is super fine it makes drawing super thin line very easy. The staying power is very good, so you need an oil-based eye makeup remover to remove it completely.
I have this in black. Previous reviews mentioned that this eye liner is not black enough. I agree that the black is not deep jet black. It's a bit greyish, though I wouldn't go as far as calling the color grey. But I do like the color cos it makes the line less harsh on my eyes.
Final verdict: This eye liner is very good value for money. The quality is excellent and the price is very affordable (around US$10). Would definitely purchase again.
This is cool. I bought this after I read the reviews on here. :) It's very easy to use and long lasting. Love it.