Am I using the same product as everyone else? This not only leaves my lids/undereye area EXTREMELY oily and greasy, it doesn't even get all of my eye makeup off. I don't even use waterproof mascara. The open mouth of the bottle causes me to spill and use way too much. The only reason I purchased this is because apparently Neutrogena has decided to quit making their eye makeup removing lotion. I will not repurchase.

This is my favorite eye makeup remover and it performs much better than many of the other drug and department store brands I've tried (Clarins, Lancôme, L'Oreal, Sonia Kashuk) and the price is good. It dissolves all eye makeup, including waterproof mascara, gel eyeliner, and cream eye shadows without irritating my eyes or leaving an oily film behind. I would prefer a squeeze top to a splash bottle for a little more control over how much product I apply to the cotton pad and to prevent spills, but that's a minor issue. I have purchased this product many, many times and I've never found another eye makeup remover that performs better for the price.

Cannot tell you how many bottles of this I have gone through! I have an extremely water proof liquid eyeliner and mascaras that take a miracle to wipe off. I put some of this on a cotton round for each eye and takes little rubbing to get everything off! I have tried a few other eye makeup removers and they all suck compared to this one. The one thing that is a negative is that it can leave some oily residue after, but i just wipe it off with a little bit of toilet paper. The bottle lasts for a very long time even if you use it every night. I LOVE this makeup remover!

Seriously. This inexpensive product ($6.50) does the job and removes your eyeshadow, liner, and mascara very easily and effectively.


There is no stinging, or eye watering. After I do the Neutrogena, I use Boscia's Makeup Breakup, over the entire face, including the eyelid area since it's so gentle and lovely. Consequently, I do not experience oily eye lids as a few posters reported.


You can't beat it. I would definitely re-purchase. It keenly removes everything without a bit of pulling, which is key in handling the eye area. I use one cotton round for both eyes.


Luv it.

I love this eye makeup remover. It's cheap, easy to find and it really works.

Cheap and really works! I wear plenty of waterproof eye makeup and this works like a charm!
Only other one that I love is Sephora Waterproof remover, but not worth the price.
Too cheap to not buy it!

What can get better than this? With just one swipe, everything is gone, even my waterproof mascara. I've tried lots of make-up removers. This one by far is the best. It's very gentle and does NOT burn my eyes at all. Though it does leave an oily residue.
All in all, this is a great product with a great price.
*Remember, products don't work the same for everybody*

This is the first dual phase makeup remover that I ever purchased, and after trying this, I haven't felt the need to try anything else (due to my own experience, compounded by the MUA reviews)! At this point, I've been through at least ten bottles of this stuff. I soak a soft cotton pad with the remover and wipe my eye makeup right off. For wp mascara, I really soak the pad and gently grip my eyelashes with it to loosen the makeup before wiping. I used to use this every night before washing my face, but now that I've found a face wash that removes my makeup really effectively (Philosophy's Purity Made Simple), I only use this when I put on a LOT of eye make up!


Pros: quickly, effectively, and GENTLY removes all makeup without stinging! Soak eyelash curlers and falsies in this stuff to clean more easily. Pretty cheap, and easy to snap up in a drugstore BOGO sale.


Cons: Leaves a slight oily residue on the skin, which doesn't bother me because I always follow with a cleanser. I'm not a big fan of the screw cap because I always knock over the bottle and spill product. continued >>

I love this make up remover. I bought it after readind reviews on mua and i am totally satisfied it does what is supposed to do. Great product.

This product does what it's supposed to: remove eye makeup. The only thing I don't like about it, is that it burns my eyes after using it. Ladies with sensitive/delicate skin like me:keep this in mind if you decide to buy this product! This lasts for a few seconds and goes away, but it's not that great of a feeling and tends to cause my eyes to get puffy when i wake up in the morning. Besides the burning, it's pretty good(: