This products sucks. It smudges even if eyeshadow primer is put on. It flakes and doesn't last all day like it said it would.

This eyeliner is so-so for me. Not the best liquid eyeliner, and not the worst either. Color is a nice, dark black. Staying power is good, but I don't have oily eyelids, so staying power is never an issue with me. Where I find the most fault with this is the applicator. It just does not create the precise, thin lines that I crave. When I want to do a heavier cat eye, this would work great, but I don't want that look every day. It was reasonably priced, but I will not repurchase again. I know there are better eyeliners out there.

* 11/15/2012*

I just threw it in the trash. Kept trying to make it work and realized i hated it. Will never buy again and don't wasted your money.

My favourite liquid eyeliner. Everyone I know who loves liquid liners says this one is the best. It dries matte, which is important to me. The packaging is typical for liquid liners, so it's sort of difficult to apply, especially for beginners. I will always re-purchase this.

I love this eyeliner. It stays on all day long. The shade blackest black is amazing. The felt tip is extremely easy to work with. The only complaint I have is it runs out rather quick. However, with the occasional bogo 50% off sales at walgreens, eases the issues.

LOVE IT
STAYS ON
LASTS LONG
SUPER BLACK
EASY TO APPLY
whats not to love!???!!?!

except for the fact that it looks like theres not a lot of product in the actual bottle :(

I have oily lids and I love that this stays on well and also cleans up without leaving badger eyes, unlike the gel liners that I have tried.

I am a repeat buyer!

Edit:
Not a repeat buyer since I tried Essence gel liners, I don't get the depth of colour from the Liquid Liner as I do with Essence).

I like it a lot, it's very pigmented and easy to use. I like that I can carry it in my purse and it's very practical. I will not buy it again because I discovered the gel liners and I fell in love with them. But it's a really good product!

This is the first eyeliner I had ever used and I've never had to switch! Its easy to apply and stays on all day!

This is honestly the best eyeliner i've ever tried.
It's greatly pigmented. It's semi-matte, has great precision, doesnt smudge, washes away really easy with water, stays true till the end of the day

The only downside to this is if u really want a dark line u have to go one more layer over it. It tends to fade a little. just make sure u really dry your eyeliner first before u curl ur lashes. otherwise your eyeliner wld transfer over to ur curler

Other than this, it's perfect!

I got this in black, the color was nice, very pigmented. But cheaper products have stayed on better. Laugh too hard, get any water on your face and this stuff is running down your cheeks!