This was the first eyeliner I ever tried when I got started with makeup 4 years ago. It's a great waterproof eyeliner. I have it in Black and it is very true to its color. It comes with a smudge stick on the the end of the stick and it comes in very handy if you want to create a smokey eye or soften up the black eyeliner. I usually use a primer before I put any products on my eyes, but with this, a primer is not needed. It's perfect if you wake up late for class or work and you just want something to look put together. Get one for home use and one for on the go. It's a great pencil that I will be buying for years to come!

I have this eye definer in 250 Emerald Sparkle, its a beautiful teal shade with some glitter in it, and boy does this sucker last all day. I use a makeup remover AND coconut oil to get it off and it is still there. It stains my skin a teal color and the base of my lashes, but it's not that big of a deal, I still love the color of this eye definer.

I have been looking for a waterproof blue eyeliner and I finally found it. This liner works (no smudges) and I didn't end up with blue underneath and in the crease of my eyes. It's a dark blue, and it makes my eyes look very white. I will buy this product again...

I really like it. Smooth, perfect line, comes with smudger which I also really like, blendable, cute sharpener which is just perfect I think. Color stayed all day long.

I have this in black, and only found it by accident - but I'm so glad I did.
It's now my ultimate waterlining pencil because it stays put longer than any other eyeliner I've ever tried!!
Comes with a handy little smudger on the other end, and is a crayon-type set-up that you wind up and down (no sharpening needed).
Love it! Repurchase for sure!

What a fantastic find! I had dreading having to buy another MUFE Aqua liner since it's $17 ,so I started looking for a drugstore option and after a couple of tries found it! This pencil stays on through workouts and super humid summer days- no racoon transfer to my under eye area. Very comparable to MUFE Aqua Eye. It applies smoothly without tugging and the smudger end is actually easier to use than a brush to soften and blur the line. Now there aren't many brown choices in their color line up(I need a little lighter brown for my under eye line- this one is a bit too dark and looks too harsh for day time use, IMO) but I'm happy I found it for my upper lash line. My only tiny complaint is that there is no warning that the pencil is getting low or running out. I just keep a backup at all times. $4.88 @ Wal Mart.

Survived a night of me walking/waiting in the rain to get into a club, and then me dancing and sweating all night int he club. It's a keeper. I love the smudger brush that it comes with, it works so well for me.

The pigmentation is only average, but its pretty smooth & gives nice lines. Also, it doesn't smear or smudge, so that's good, but it also doesn't last very long. I said I'd rebuy, but I'd probably stick with my Revlon Colorstay, or Neutrogena when its on sale.

--[edit]--
So this review was on the charcoal-type color. I think it was a bad one, 'cause I have this in black as well & its VERY well pigmented. It also goes on like.. smoothly (definitely kohl-like), but if you're not careful, its very easy to go off track and it'll make the same, dark, line where you don't want it. I haven't worn this all day or anything, because I never use black, but just taking it off with [good] makeup remover was easy enough, but it took work (not tugging, rigorous swiping work, but keep having to go over it work). I might rebuy my charcoal one, because I was very impressed with the black color. Besides, they're cheap ($5USD & the kohl ones, which have good reviews, are like $3-4!), so I won't be at too much of a loss, especially if I get it BOGOF.

This is my favorite eyeliner so far! I love the fact that it's not a pencil, so you don't have to worry about sharpening it and getting it all over the place. It also glides very smoothly on! You don't have to rub it on like you do with a lot of eye liners. Plus it has the little crowns on the end, super cute lol.

I have it in 240- Aqua Sparkle and it works quite well. I like the smudger on the end, the colour is really quite vibrant, and it does last all day. I also found that appliction is harder then Annabelle Kohl Eyeliners, but still pretty smooth and I like that you don't have to sharpen it. The colour comes off at the slightest touch.