I really love this eyeliner. I have it in black (0L), purple (6L), and a pretty peacock blue color (12L), and I use them almost every day. They are the only eyeliner that I have found with real staying power on the waterlines. When I put it on in the morning, I only have to touch up once or twice before midnight. I hate that they are so expensive, because the color selection is great and I want them all. I will definitely re-purchase when I run out!

I usually use Urban Decay's 24/7 line of eyeliners because I love the way they glide on and stay put. I ran out of my black liner (Zero) so I went to Sephora to re-purchase. It was sold out so I decided to give Aqua Eyes a try (the darkest color available in waterproof was 1L). Used it last night and this stuff does not glide on at all. I couldn't even get a line of color on my eyelid. What little of a line I did get, I had to go over with another Urban Decay eyeliner to at least make it a true line and not choppy. What color I did get from this product was very light and not wearable.

Well, I was searching for a pearl/white eyeliner to use it on my waterline. I went to Sephora and stopped by the MUFE ecounter, and I put my eye on this aqua eyeliner in the 14 L tone. I tried it on my hand, it felt quite good, so I inmediately bought it (I know it's my fault). When I got home I tried it on my waterline and I was disappointly surprised because it didn`t even show on my waterline. Was I doing something wrong? Why me? I tried almost until my eyes were irritated. I don't know how the other lovely colours work, but this is not good, at least for me. I can return it. I don't know what to do it with it. In the meantime I'll continue using my NYX milk.

I bought this liner after being unsatisfied with Urban Decay's 24/7 pencils. However, like any other pencil liner I've tried, it still smudged on my lower lids and a bit on my upper lids, though the smudging is DEFINITELY less severe than what the 24/7 pencils gave me. I like the fact that the creamy formula glides on smoothly, without tugging; and the colour (1L - Star Black, I think) is perfect for me - it's a pretty soft black, less harsh than pitch black liners and thus more suitable for everyday wear.

I own 1L (dark grey color. 0L seemed a bit too dark and intense for me) to line my waterlines, and it works fabulously. No smudging, and stays put the whole day unlike some eyeliners that disappear after an hour or two. Will definitely repurchase.

This line is so good. It does not budge at all. I can go swimming with it on and it will still be in place after. I have the purple, black and brown. I love this line and it is a bit expensive since it is HE, but worth it, as it last a long time and only one stroke will be good all day long. Cute packaging.

I love this eyeliner. It is the only eyeliner pencil I have found that doesn't vanish during the hot summer months. I bought one for each of my daughters and they love it too. It is the only pencil my daughter in Florida uses - and she has tried everything!

Better than regular eye liner, but I find it smudges and does not last all day. Much of it ends up in the crease of my eye lids. My eyelids are very oily.

i bought the MAKE UP FOR EVER Aqua Eyes Holiday Collection from sephora a few weeks ago. the packaging was cute and for $35 you get to try out 5 colors:
- Bronze 10L (metallic bronze)
- Purple 11L (metallic purple)
- Turquoise 7L (light turquiose sheen)
- Mat Black 0L (black)
- Iridescent Navy Blue 3L (navy blue sheen)

pretty decent price. they were really small at a mere .025oz each and the colors were so pretty! i personally loved all of them. however, there is always a bad side to makeup. the eyeliner didnt stay on for very long! it smudged at the corners of my eyes and especially the eyelids. after 2-3 hours, the eyeliner on my eyelid disappeared and reappeared on my upper eyelids. it was terrible. :( i dont think i'll repurchase but they have the most amazing colors!

I have a problem with eyeliner not staying on my eyes for long and smudging and making my eyes look messing and over done. This pencil slides on easily and stays there. I put on just alittle of my 18L cranberry (?) colored pencil and it stays on all day. I smudge a little with a Q-tip and it stays on and comes off very easily with my waterproof make-up remover. It works the best when it was very sharp, so remember to sharpen after or before each use!