I REALLY wanted to love this because it gets raves upon raves. I HATE it. idk if I got a "bad" one or what...Everybody always says this is hard to remove blah blah. Well with me, this liner transfers from my lash line to my crease (never happened with my fluidline or with the hip cream liners). Its SOOOOOOO NOT cute. I tried making the line thin - it didn't work. I tried closing my eyes for a couple of min for it to dry - didnt work either. This even smudged on me. Maybe I need to leave the cap off for a while so that it can dry a little.
I really wished it would have worked for me because it is actually affordable...grr.
It is very pigmented and goes on really smoothly. It is thinner than the HIP brand creme liners but I like it anyway. I use my HIP brush to put it on-- the one that comes with the package is totally useless and makes a line an inch thick. That went into the trash quickly. Otherwise, this product is awesome. It did transfer onto my lower lid a bit after a nap but what eyeliner doesn't? It always does for me. The packaging is cheap and plastic but for $4 I'm not going to insist on a glass case with the frills. Hopefully this won't dry out on me. I'll update if it does. I highly recommend trying this out before shelling out $$$ for MAC or BB.
I LOVE this eyeliner!!! i always tightline my eyes, and line my lower lash line, and waterline often. I've used Mac kohls, estee lauder, chanel, dior, cover girl...they all would end up under my eyes, and i hated it! i thought high end brands were the best, but i was wrong. this is amazing!
i use my mac 269 angled brush. i've never tried WnW brush, since i love my mac so much. i like a black black liner! and this is! you just need to dab your brush in VERY lightly to pick up color. it's a creamy consistency. use a light hand! be gently when applying. it's midnight black, which i love, it stays put where you put it! thank god! it doesn't smudge, it doesn't fall onto my cheeks. it smudges very naturally into my lashes! it blends in nice strokes if you want to extend past your eyeline. just make sure you keep the lid on tight. i've had it for 2 months, and it stays moist. it has never dried. and i know this will last me a very long time! i love it, and recommend.
This was my first creme liner. When I applied it on my eyelids, it was nice and pigmented. If I messed up, I could easily wipe off my mistake with a Q-tip. I used an oil based cleanser to take it off. Beware, it isn't easy to take off, but a lot of eyemakeup is hard to remove anyways...
I would've given this product 5 stars if the angeled brush wasn't stupid. The bristles hurt and it makes the process of applying the creme liner longer...Thus, I highly recommend buying another brush from Sephora or Ulta. Of course you can't expect much from drugstore brushes.
I wanted to try and practice with an inexpensive creme liner to see if i liked it before buying a high end creme liner. and WOW. this stuff is amazing. it is really creamy and glides on very easily. what surprised me was how dark it was with one stroke. the brush that the liner came with didn't work that well for me. i used a mac 266 instead. the liner did not smudge after you let it dry and it lasted all day. i am so happy with the quality of this product that i'll probably just stick with this creme liner especially since i am saving money that could go towards something else. $4 is a bargain and wouldn't hurt to at least try this product.
The brush is ick and so is the packaging shape, but it is a beautiful, rich dark black with a great texture and goes on smoothly. I use my own thin liner brush and this works great. I have used MAC Fluidliner, Bobbi Brown's gel liner as well as various liquid liners and this has all of them beat....and the price???? You can't go wrong!
Wet n Wild is a brand that I abandoned years ago. I've always thought of it in league with lipsmackers and Bon bon. Just a junky line for tweens with little pocket money and not idea about makeup. I am so happy I was wrong! After reading so many good reviews on here I had to try it. It took me 2 tries to get it right, but since then it's been a dream. I despise all fluid eyeliner as it's so difficult to apply and it tends to get slightly chunky. And I've tried MAC, Stila, BB all the way down to Revlon and Maybelline with the same gross results. Wet n Wild has not only a winner here, but the trump card. It's a BLACK liner that glides on so simply and beautifully that you can't go wrong. And the price! I paid $2.18 for mine at a WinCo. I already bought both of my sisters their own pots of this and they are in love. Quality can't be beat. And the price makes me feel like I'm ripping them off! ETA I am on my second one because a "friend" stole most of my makeup. However I think they changed the brush. My new one is much softer than my last and it's not scratchy at all.
I bought this product in the beginning of this year. I saw it from someones blog that week and she was raving how good it was. So I went to my local drugstore that weekend and decided to buy it. Since it was really cheap, compare to the products I use (i.e. sonia kashuk, Loreal's HIP & M.A.C.) I wanted to give it a try. I was thinking "hey the price is good and if the quality is good maybe ill switch to this." The day I bought the product they were having a sale on Wet n' Wild Cosmetics, I think it was 20% off so I was sold. I believe the product was like 3.99 and 20%. I was so excited to buy and use it right a way. So the next day getting ready to go out and starting to put on my face I was kind of hestitant to use the little brush. (I had a bad experience using the little eyeliner brush from Loreal's HIP eyeliner - I thought the brush was hard to handle and brush hair was too rough for my eyelid) Anyways, I went ahead and used my own eyeliner brush. The texture of the eyeliner was creamy which I like because I work well with creme eyeliners because I have oily skin. Once I put the eyeliner it wasn't what I expected. It didnt glide on as smooth as the thought and actually it was difficult to even put on. So i tried removing it and it was also difficult. I was disappointed with this product and I wouldn't want to buy this again. This is what I experience but I read other people's review and I might even try it again.
I love this product-it's inexpensive, highly-pigminted and lasts doesn't smudge. Application takes a little practice if you want a smudged smokey look vs. a fine line against the lash line but it's well worth it. Once the product has set, it will stay on until you remove it, even through a strenuous workout (including swimming). I find waterproof eye makeup remover works best to get every last bit off but for someone who always has smudges and smears, this is the cheapest product I've seen in years that WORKS! My only disappointment is that Wet N' Wild only has this on two colors, black and an aubergine/purple. It would be nice to see it in a brown too.
I got this creme liner because It had many good reviews and also because it was 2 bucks. I don't like it. I have extremely oily lids and within an hour of applying this I have raccoon eyes. I have the MAC fluidline and that is so much better than this. The only good thing that I liked, aside from it being really cheap, is that it is extremely pigmented. The applicator that comes with it is pretty good but a little too big for my small asian eyes.