Haven't bought Wet n Wild in years but I heard good things about this. Great product at a great price. Mine was a little over 4 dollars. A great dupe for MAC blacktrack, fluidline it might take a teensy bit more effort but at the price it's an amazing deal. Stays on all day.

The brush that it comes with doesn't work very well, I would recommend a different one. Packing is small and cute.

It was hard to find as not all Wet n Wild displays had it, although they all should!

Awesome product! I dislike the brush it came with but I just use other lining brushes I have. I was turned off to gel/creme liners because every one I'd tried before wasn't very pigmented and was kind of a hassle to apply. I picked this up at buy on get one sale on Wet N Wild products and this has become a staple! It goes on so smoothly and it's almost effortless to get a nice line (unlike with most liquid liners). Stays on my lid and waterline all day (it's actually kinda hard to get off, even with makeup remover!). Overall, such a good value.

i normally dont' buy anything from wet n wild because i've thought of wet n wild as a brand for tweens who are just starting out with makeup and can't afford things that are of better quality and higher price.. but boy am i glad that i gave this a try.

really good creme liner for my waterline. nothing stays on my waterline.... and i've tried a lot of things... i've used urban decay's 24/7 liner in zero, i've tried revlon eyeliners, mac fluidline, bobbi brown's gel liner, cliniques cream liner, almays and a bunch of other drugstore eyeliners and nothing worked..... i got this eyeliner as a gift from my friend. she had to order this online as she wasn't able to find it anywhere here where we live in Canada. i'm so glad that you gave me this because i have not found anything that even comes close to how long this stays on my waterline. the liner itself come in a little plastic jar that looks like a UFO and an angle brush that i threw away the second i got it because it was just too thick and prickly. what i have found to be the best way to apply this eyeliner is by using an old pencil eyeliner that i no longer use and dip it into the cream liner and then apply it directly only my waterline. it stays for hours and hours and hours!!!

i would definetly by this again and probably in the eggplant colour as well. i hear that the colour isn't as deep as the black... and may i add.. the black is really really really black. WAY blacker than the fluidline that i have from mac.

Okay! This review is coming from someone who never uses Wet n' WIld products... On a whim, I was not happy with my stila smudgepot eyeliner as it dried out quickly! Yucky! I need to have my eyeliner- so I went to the drugstore, and was just looking for a 'quick' fix... I ended up purchasing this. I AM Thrilled I did! It works even better than the Stila brand,(which I paid a lot for)- and this was only a few dollars! It goes on smoothly, lasts untill you take it off, does not run and does a great job of application on my eye lids! I really do feel this is a wonderful alternative to spending too much $ on higher end products. I have had this for several months now, and it is still creamy! Yay for wet n' wild! Although I am not a big fan of the brush it came with- other than that it is well worth trying out!!

I would buy this again in a heartbeat. Wow. This stuff is amazing and really lives up to its glowing reviews.
I have tried other liquid/cream eyeliners and absolutely hated them. I swore I would never use liquids or creams just because of how fussy they are.
This stuff makes application soooo easy and stressfree. I use Quo's liner brush, make a quick dip in the pot, and draw one smooth line across my eyelid. The colour is a true black, it lasts ALL DAY, and doesn't smudge or cause me stress by going all over the place.
Love it!

loooooove this so much! Ihave a sleek liner which is much thicker in consistency and no matter what i try i cant get it off the brush! This baby however is awesome, i wouldnt call it a gel more of a cream, and a little goes a long long way it is soooo richly pigmented even more so than my sisters BB which i was lemming till i got my hands on this. Not keen on the packaging just because the lid makes it look like a tester, the brush is better than i expected for essentially what is a bonus and is dense enough to work with this product well. Also it doesnt clog the brush with its consistency. I have not been more in love with an eyeliner since the urban decay 24/7. i just wish this came in more colours as im not sure eggplant is for me- and this product has single handedly killed every lemming i had for BB and mac fluidlines. its a must try- ooooo one point is it is a mission to remove although loreal demaq works well and clinique cleansing balm

Really awesome. When I was younger, Wet n Wild was the cheesy brand teenagers bought but they seem to have revamped their line and introduced some quality products and still at a budget-friendly price. This eyeliner is amazingly easy to apply, has the best staying power I've ever seen (my one complaint is that you need some hardcore makeup remover to get it off--baby oil won't really do; neither will leaving it on for days and letting it 'wear' off), and the color is rich and dark. After using it a couple times I decided to buy the eggplant variety too. I don't love the packaging; it's novel and cute, but not very functional, and after carrying it around in my purse the plastic is showing some cracks. The brush is also not the greatest but not terrible for a free brush and is a perfect size to carry around with you, in case you have to put your 'going out face' on at work or something. The other problem is if you're going to use another one of your brushes, it's quite difficult to remove.
Update: After owning this product for about five months, it's suddenly shriveled up and dried out! Big disappointment. Maybe I didn't screw the lid back on tightly enough, or maybe that's just what it does.

If you want a smooth application without skipping this liner is for you. I would never in a million years have bought this if it wasn't for MUA reviews. Cheap (about $3.99 at Walgreen's if not on sale). I use my Bobbi Brown liner brush and have a very easy beautiful long-lasting line. I even use it on my lower rim which I've never done before (with a light hand). Doesn't sting; doesn't bleed; doesn't settle in wrinkles. I have tried every liner imaginable, high and low end, and this is by the far the best. I have oily eyelids and this doesn not end up on my upper lid. Perfect liner. You can't go wrong giving it a try--it's so inexpensive.

This product to me is wayyy better than MAC blacktrack!! The WnW eyeliner is darker, cheaper, and stays on longer than blacktrack. I got mines at Walgreens for about 4 dollars and it was the last one. They do have other colors like dark blue, green, and I think red. I highly recommend it! My eyelids are really oily but if you use the Urban Decay Primer Potion it really stays on great.

HG gel eyeliner!!! This is a must! I had read some glowing reviews on this and decided to try it for myself. I have combination/oily skin, and over the course of the day my eyelids do get oily, causing my eyeliner to smudge, but not this one! I even use it as a base for black eyeshadows and keeps my makeup crease-free and perfect all day. Can't go wrong with this one, especially since the price is like what, $4 at the most?