Who loves this so much? I've bought it twice and both times it clumped, ran and smudged. I threw it out. I like to have a smokey eye from my eyeshadows not my mascara. UGH!!
I'm glad that I'm not the only one who thinks this product isn't worth the "hype." I'm lucky to have long curly lashes, but when I use this mascara, it doesn't enhance my lashes at all. It smears and it's too wet. Good for people who like the natural look, but if your lashes are too long, that stuff will get all over your eyes. I prefer Voluminous (L'Oreal) or Triple Mascara (Cover Girl).
This is awful and left my lashes skimpy and clumpy. Why all the hype?
I used to use this-its clumpy and not good-but since then I've found Mascaras that are WAY better-Mary Kay and Clinique Glossy are way better!!
I could not stand this mascara. Very goopy and clumpy. I have definitely used better. Do not recommend.
I know lots of people love this, but I found it to be very wet. I have pretty long lashes so I had dots of mascara above and below my eyes because I couldn't help blinking before it dried.
I love this mascara!! It legnthens my lashes but (and this is why it got 4 instead of 5)it doesn't do too well a job at thickening them. But the job it does at legthening is superb, the colors are great, and i think my lashes are becoming softer as i use this thanks to the conditioner in the mascara. My whole appearance is improved when i wear this wonderful mascara.
I personally love this. It's great if you're going for that 'sophisticated' look. It didn't clump as much as my other ones. I just <3 this!!
I always come back to this stuff for a good, basic mascara. I love that the wand is smaller than a lot of other mascaras because I find that it makes application easier. I wipe the excess off with a tissue before applying (I do this with all mascaras) and it looks great. Love it!
If you are young and have just started to use make-up, this will be a basic must-have. It hardly ever clumps(even professional make-up artiste says so!),lengthen ur lashes, thus defining your eyes gently. I used this on days when I don't feel like using make-up except mascara bcoz mascara is my favourite must-have. However, i would not buy it again bcoz i prefer mascara thats dramatically lengthens my lashs(i'm an asian). There's this brand in Singapore and Japan(and probably other Asian countries) called FASIO. Their mascara is really great in creating dramatic lashes. but abit hard to remove though. Maybelline great lash is very easy to remove bcoz its very light...
EDIT 04/11/05: i reviewed tis product abt 2yrs ago.i could stil remember e hype n raves abt tis classic mascara. however, im sad to say tat new technology are overtaking tis classic mascara. lots of mascaras out dere are able to create a better effect than great lash. awwww...