I am crazy-in-love with this eyeliner. I own two Bourjous waterproof eyeliners (a teal-green one and a metallic grey one) that I simply adore, and this N.Y.C. waterproof eyeliner is just as good, if not better, than those. So far, I've only been able to find the black and dark brown colors, but I hear there are more...anyone know where to find all the colors offered??
Anyway, this eyeliner goes on smooth and strong, and it's easy to make a tiny, thin line, or a bold, thick one. I tend to like the smudgy look under my eyes, and this eyeliner will only smudge if I really work at it with my finger. This stuff is tough!!
I'm starting to realize that after years of thinking that N.Y.C. cosmetics was an el cheapo brand, it's probably one of the best make-up lines I've ever used. I'm so glad I gave it a shot!!
i got the mink and black color... i bought this for 3.99 on bogo sale at cvs.. this one really stays put whole day, it doesnt smudges on me, it's easy to apply, so clean and precise.. and what i really like abt this even it says waterproof, it is easily remove... this is the only waterproof eyeliner i have and i love it so much.. i'll buy other colors..
I bought this because I was out of eyeliner and thought that I would just use it until I bought a more expensive one. Forget about the expensive one, this is fantastic!! It applies smoothly and lasts all day. They have a nice color selection too(it's hard to find a good waterproof plum eyeliner). This is my favorite pencil eyeliner!
This eyeliner really isn't anything special. It smudges halfway through the day, just like pretty much every eyeliner pencil I've used. I like that the consistency is creamy and glides on easily, but otherwise this is pretty meh.
this is the BEST waterproof liner i ever bought!! i have this in mink, a warm golden brown liner..very similar to mac teddy. This does not smudge at all and it stays on all day. BTW i do have very oily lids and i do some crazy lashes that somehow liner travels on then on to my lids =( And so far i do not see any liner on my lids! I'm going to black, smoke plum and restock this color as well!! probably going to buy all the black liner that i can find since i loooove black liners =D I think this is going to replace my MAC engraved liner that i use all the time. note: i did try UD 24/7 liner, stila smudge pot (good but time consuming), mac fluidline (good as well), clinique all types of liner....and so on. THIS IS THE BEST and it's ONLY $3
This eyeliner is amazing! It goes on creamy and even, and sharpens easily. Forget the more expensive eyeliners, this is worth it.
i love this eyeliner. it definitely stays on all day but sometimes it smudges, which isn't that big of a deal considering its price. i'm very pleased with this. plus it comes in all different colors. i recommend this.
this has been my "go to" eyeliner. it's very creamy and easy to apply. yes, it does smudge.. not too bad. im probably going to buy this again until i find a better one that actually stays on ALL day. :)
This has got to be the BEST most inexpensive waterproof eyeliner in the market! Such a drugstore gem! First its dirt cheap and second, it stays on all day! Only con is that you may need a eye makeup remover because this eyeliner just stays on all day. Other than that, it doesn't budge or smear at all! Will continue to purchase in all colors!
A great eyeliner that has true staying power and is pretty darn cheap! I bought this on a whim because I needed some kind of plum eyeliner asap and I was more than pleasantly surprised at it's quality. Definitely a drug store gem. Will buy again.