I don't know why I even bothered to purchase this product. I knew nothing about it, but needed a dark matte black eyeliner.
The color is good.
The eyelining brush is extremely hard, rather than a soft bristle, which makes it hard to use for me.
The price is decent-not expensive, but you get what you pay for.
I will not repurchase because I do not like the brush.

Best liquid eyeliner I have ever used. I use black-brown, which looks black on me and for some reason has better staying power than the black. This stays on ALL DAY! Unless you rub your eyes, this will not come off. My eyelids tend to get oily towards the end of the day, however this eyeliner does not give me that black line in the crease. Great stuff overall and very user friendly for those who have never used liquid liner or have a hard time applying liner. Also, it's super easy to remove if you make a mistake. Lasts a VERY long time, especially if you don't use it everyday. I'm still using a bottle that I bought 2 years ago!

I really like the felt-pen-style tip of this eyeliner, and the bottle itself is quite attractive. I like having decent control over the thickness of my line, and this product is good for that. My gripes are that the formula could be just a tiny bit thicker so that the color is more evenly distributed, though I find that is the problem with most liquid eyeliners. Staying power is not bad at all, as long as you keep your fingers away from your eyes.

Like it! It gives a thin, precise line but of course is buildable like any other liquid liner. It stays put, dries quickly, and is easy to correct if u make a mistake. Great value for the price.

I like the color selection. My skin is very fair, and I like the bronze when I want something less dramatic than black-brown. (Black-brown is my version of black, since my skin's so light.)

The only downside is that the marker tip is very, very stiff. I like 'em a little more flexible at the end, but I may get used to it. If I do get used to the tip, I'll give it a 5.

I am a liquid eyeliner idiot. So I gave up on liquid liners for a long time. On a whim, I tested out a Palladio display at Longs Drugs with these marker-type liners (not the same liners in the pics on the right). I couldn't believe how easy it was to use & they had a fabulous selection of colors. I purchased dark brown & have been using it every day now for 2 weeks. The design makes it so easy to apply. It wears all day on my oily lids (with UDPP as a base). No flaking or fading, even after some of my 16 hour days. I purchased the eggplant liner yesterday & plan on eventually buying all their colors. FYI, these are designed exactly the same as CG's marker liquid eyeliners (Line Exact), but the CG ones fade & flake on me. Anyways, I am incredibly impressed by the quality of these. Only $6 too.

The only eyeliner I have found that doesn't end up in the creases of my eyelids! Thank you MUA for introducing me to this super product. I have now purchased bronze, taupe, black forest and blue. Taupe is great for everyday; bronze adds a little more, the black forest and blue are perfect for more dramatic eyes.

I have no idea why I use this continually and actually think it's a good eyeliner. This morning the results were so bad, that I had to wipe it all off and start over, with some eyeliner sealer and shadow. Not only does this stuff BURN my eyelid when I put it on, but IMO it's hard to get a precise line. I know what I'm doing, but this stuff just makes it really hard for me. I will not repurchase, and I probably won't use again, finally I'm coming to my senses after using this stuff for the past 2 years off and on.

i bought this at sally beauty because the saleswoman suggested it. BOY WAS SHE WRONG! after 2 hours it smudged all over my face[oily skin] and made me look like a raccoon.

horrible buy, would NEVER buy again.

i prefer these to revlon's liquid e/l cause of the better formula and price. goes on very precise and true to the color although i do get a bit of a sting when i first apply it for some reason. luckily it goes away shortly after. hasn't left any irritations or rashes on my eyelids so ill continue to use it. thanks palladio!

Perfect. I use this every night. Such a nice consistency and the applicator makes it so easy to apply. It's not waterproof but I can take a shower with it and don't have to worry about it running. My favorite liquid liner I have ever tried.