Of the five I tried, this is my second favorite (after Pink Blossom) - and I think the reason is because of the production. Color is not uniform in the tinted balms - I am as pale as they get, and Rose should have had deeper, more uniform color than Pink Blossom. It did not. What color it did have was lovely. You should be able to put on tinted balm the way you'd put on chapstick, but the uneven color in the tube means you have to stop and check. As someone who can put on lipstick and stay in the lines without a mirror (Dave Letterman? I have your Stupid Human Trick of the Year!), I am not interested in stopping for something I bought at Fred Meyer.
I would have been mislead by the size of the product had I not shamelessly peeked before buying. >< This shows up as a pretty tint on me, some actual color! I wanted a rosy red balm, and here it is. Not too bright or warm, just rosy and healthy. Just a small amount of gloss, looks very natural. I wouldn't call this the most moisturizing balm, but it does add some moisture, I usually carry another balm with me just in case. The price is kind of ridiculous ($6.99 I think?) but I'd pay it for this color. Really. I would. Also has a light and pleasant sweet smell.
I agree about the misleading packaging- you think you are getting a jumbo, chubby balm and instead you get a rather small, chapstick sized tube. However, that said I love this balm as it adds just the most most subtle hint of rosy colour to your lips - it is not a lipstick after all. If you want a more pigmented balm like product then try the Bobbi Brown or Laura Mercier equivalents, of course they are more expensive. I find that even though I have quite pigmented lips naturally, this just makes them look and feel so much better. I like that this very discreet and doesn't look like you are wearing make up , it isn't as gloosy as the Fresh balms and the colours are more muted perfect for days when you want a very low key , not quite made up look .
I was looking for a red or rosy balm that would add some moisture in the winter. On me, this hardly shows up, even if I pack it on, which is odd because it looks so red in the tube. The packaging led me to believe it was a much bigger balm than it is (it's chapstick sized).
It feels pretty moisturizing on, and has some kind of a fruity scent (I want to say cherry?) but I feel kind of silly paying $6.99 for glorified chapstick. If you want an appreciable red tint, give this a pass. A very light one, it might be up your alley.
I got this in a set with one of the Lip Shimmers in the skinny packaging. This is nothing like the original Burts' Bees lip balm. It's not minty, and it is somewhat drying on my lips. I much prefer the ones in the skinny packaging, they are nothing like this. The color is very pretty and natural, but what's the point if it messes up your lips and makes them dry?
Out of the other tinted lip balm's I have tried from Burt's Bees, I like Rose the best. It's not too much, it's really just enough if you're on the run and want a tiny bit of color and some moisture. It's a very light tint.
I'm a self proclaimed lip balm junkie and this stuff is awful! It dried out my lips. I think all Burt's Bees lip products are junk but this takes the freakin' cake. Thank goodness I could return it.
I purchased Rose, Hibiscus, and Pink Blossom on a tinted lipbalm binge. I find that they are moisturising and have the perfect amount of colour payoff (it's a "tint" afterall). The packaging, like everyone else mentioned, is superfluous (shame on you Burt!) and definitely adds to the $7something price tag.
Because everyone here mentioned that Rose was a dupe of Fresh's Rose I did a swatch test. I checked it in the sun, in the shade, and in artificial lighting. While Burt's Rose is close, it's not a dead-on dupe. Burt's was obviously warmer, peachy-based, while Fresh's was cooler, berry-based. I love both of them and find that both provide a good amount of moisture to my lips, though I am partial to the tone of Burt's Rose. HTH.
I love this. I bought rose as well as red dahlia because I couldn't decide on which one without trying them on first. The rose colour made me look young and fresh adding that hint of colour to my lips that look natural and pretty. The smell is delicious, and it feels moisturizing and nice on the lips. The packaging could be nicer as it's just in a plain boring brown normal lip balm wind-up tube but still does the job and applies fine.
The red dahlia colour is not as nice on me as rose, I feel it makes me look older whereas rose is a brighter fresh pink and the closest thing I've found to a natural looking touch of colour to my lips.
I don't wear lip gloss much at all so this tinted lipbalm is the perfect substitute for me, it will have a permanent place in my handbag!
Much better than the shimmers, I finally got this on sale when wal-mart was liquidating(?)
I was almost afraid the rose color would be to vibrant - ha! This is the most subtle tinted lip balm I've used in a while - It just make your lips slightly more flushed. I like the smooth feel - it's loaded with natural oils, including coconut, (so don't use if you hate coconut or are allergic)
This BB's line really is similar to the Fresh Sugar one, I'd say Fresh's rose is slightly more gold and tastes amazing, but I'd rather spend 7 dollars than 23 on the same color and concept.
EDIT: Except instead of moisturizing, it dries your lips out. I've stopped using it since. Simple, cheap lip glosses are more protective.