I hated this mascara. I used the waterproof version, and my eyelids kept sticking together. It never felt like it dried at all, just got tacky. It was terrible to remove, too. I couldn't even scrape it off, it was like tar.

I dont like this mascara. i have thin sraight lashes that dont curl easily. i usually put on waterproof mascara on first to hold the curl then apply my volumizing mascara. This stuf is sooooooo incredibly thick! It looks gloppy everytime! the only way to make it work is to scrape off the majority the mascara off the brush then apply it over the waterproof mascara. it weighs down your lashes ALOT. it really isnt worth the trouble. oh by the way it kind of looked blue in the light. i really dont like that!

I don't hate this mascara but I don't love it either. I just got it and these are my first impressions: the brush is large but the bristles are not close together--> I think this makes not clumps in the traditional sense but it makes the lashes bunch together. The formula isn't too wet nor too dry. The mascara would be better I think if its bristles were closer. I used this first then went over it with maybelline's full and soft to go through the lashes better. The black is very black which is nice. All in all jsut okay, could be better. It claims to be bigger and better than voluminous, which is thought was okay but tended to dry out and get clummy. I don't there is a comparison between the 2 mascaras but that's just me :) continued >>

I used this a couple years ago and for some reason strayed... I'm so glad I found my way back. It can be a bit clumpy, but I just love the formula so much that I just go through my lashes with another mascara wand I have. This product seems to just glide on and does a good job of adding volume to my puny asian lashes. I do use a separate lengthening mascara if I want to add length. Doesn't flake or smudge.

I also love the sleek black tube this comes in.

This worked amazing for me, made my lashes longer than they have ever been, i didn't think i would be able to find anything better than maybelline's collosal (bad spelling) the stuff in the bright yellow tube, but this has outdone it. no clumping either!

An average mascara. I didn't find this thickened my lashes much and didn't make them very long. The brush is underwhelming as the bristles aren't dense enough to grab the lashes and push them upwards.
It's supposed to make lashes twelve times thicker than another L'Oreal mascara - I would like to see this demonstrated to their customers in an online clip because it certainly didn't work for me. Really disappointing. Back to YSL and Dior.

I love this mascara! It's pretty decent for a drugstore brand. It doesn't clump easily and gives my lashes alot more volume. What I love about it the most is that it doesn't smudge!! Wonderful!! :)

I have this mascara and i think it works great for volumizing and lengthening! People tell me that my lashes look really long, pretty, and also ask me if im wearing false eyelashes, which i dont. The only con is that it tends clumping a little after a few coats. But other than that its awesome!

The brush on this mascara looks NOTHING like what is on the packaging and in the ads. When the brush bristles themselves are clumping together you know the mascara is bad. At least it was cheap.

I'm so happy I bought this mascara. I usually spend $20 or so on high end mascaras that don't give me the results I want. But this makes my lashes extremely volumized and even lengthens them slightly. It does dry a little crunchy but I've pretty much found that mascara does that to my lashes so I'll get over it. But I will definately repurchase- I haven't found a mascara that volumizes my lashes like this does in a long time.