I absolutely LOVE this eyeliner, none to minimal smudging. Lasts half of an entire day/night without reapplication and even with the reapplying it only needs a slight touch up. Colors are very true and gorgeous!

This is a fantastic liner! This is very comparable to two liners that I own: Revlon grow luscious liner, and the NYX slide on eye pencils. All of these pencils have the same creamy formula and long wear time. I like the rich black color and I am in love with the smudger that comes attached to this! This liner goes fast, though...I used up so much of it in the few short weeks I've had it :( I feel like some of the other products I mentioned work just as well and are just as pigmented but somehow last longer. This is not HG for me, but it does deserve 5 stars for being an amazingly pigmented, easy to use, and long wearing liner!

I have tried about all eyeliners, and none have stayed where I've put it. This does! I applied it this morning, I've worked all day and came home and washed my car in the hot sun. I was sweating, but this eyeliner stayed put! I'm so glad I have finally found an eyeliner that does this! I bought it in brown, and it goes on smooth and dark. I can't wait to buy the other colors as well.

This product goes on smooth and dark. It lasts all day. It can rub off though if you rub your eyes. I absolutely love this product. It's the one product that the husband does not state that I only did half my eye. LOL.

This liner is fantastic! It's SUPER black and stays on like no other. Put it this way, one day when I was wearing this, my dad came over trying to be funny and RUBBED HIS THUMB ON MY EYE. I freaked out and looked in the mirror only to find that my makeup HADN'T BUDGED. I don't care who you are, that's dedication. Not to mention this stuff is waterproof like nobody's freaking business! Definitely worth $8.

It is impossible to make thin lines with this pencil but it has a great creamy texture so you can swipe some on a thin liner brush if you're too lazy to find a cream liner. If I apply this on the waterline it will smear down after only a few hours. Despite it's imperfections, it's a pretty decent drugstore liner as it lasts a long time on my lids and has great color payoff.

I'm happy to say that I have finally ended my hunt for a good inexpensive liner for my waterline. This liner is BLACK and it stays on longer than any other eyeliner I've tried. It's very rare (atleast for me) to find an eyeliner that is soft for the waterline and won't run/smudge after a couple hours. I also wear contact lenses and haven't had a problem with blurry vision or make-up disposits. Then again that could have something to do with the quality of my lenses. I don't bother using pencils on my upper eyelids, that's what clinique gel liner was invented for.

Pros: intense color, smudge proof, glides on, and price.
Only con: Pain in the behind to remove. Might take more than a couple of washes.

Overall, I love this product! Best of all is the money I saved. Goodbye $20 eyeliners, hello drugstore!

This is a cinch to apply. Really creamy and soft, no tugging. Can be difficult to get a thin line though because it's so soft. I bought the dark brown one and the colour is really intense, it lasts a very long time too (10+ hours). However, my sensitive eyes reacted badly to it like other reviewers. Slightly bloodshot, red, teary eyes within 15 mins of application. I've never reacted to an eyeliner like that before. Tried it out 5/6 times, each time I had the same reaction.

Only thing good about it is easy to apply very smoothly.
However, smugged too easily, I can't draw thin line.
Whenever I tried to apply, line is drawer very thick.
I don't like it, I returned it

its just like pencil liner, doesnt give fell of liquid liner at all

I got the WORST eye reaction to this. My eyes were so watery and they even burned! I also experienced the blurred vision others have mentioned. I should say that I do have very sensitive eyes so I have a lot of bad reactions to e/l on my waterline (and even not on my waterline!) but this one was the worst. If you have sensitive eyes I don't recommend this.