I decided to give liquid eyeliner a 2nd chance, because I was tired of cleaning my eyeliner brush everyday from using MAC black track fluid line. While fluid line works very well, It was just an hassle cleaning the brush everyday because the hairs would harden after every application. So I did my reviews and decided to give this Liquid Liner a try, and I LOVE IT! The color goes on super dark, darker than black track fluid line and it gives the perfect clean cat eye look if you know how to use the applicator. Thats what I love about this product! With a steady application your eyeliner would look super clean, the product also doesn't smudge which is another plus, after you let it dry for like 20 seconds. But I found my HG liquid eye liner! I recommend anyone who is looking for a liquid eye liner, to try this one! it retails at $18, a little expensive but worth it :) hope this helped

i love this! most liners do not stay on my lashline! they just end up traveling down my eye area and the ends of my eyes. i cannot use pencil because i just can't control it. liquid and creme/gels are the only things i would use as liner on my top lashline. l'oreal linuer intense is nice but the formula of that liquid liner would flake on me by the end of the day. other gel liners just dont stay put.

this liner is amazing! it has a really nice thin brush. it's flexible but sturdy. it makes lining your eyes a breeeze! and it makes the winged eyeliner look super easy. it does not smudge, flake, or travel any where. it stays put all day.

IN. LOVE! I have so many black eyeliners, from high-end to drugstore, and have yet to find one I completely, completely love (except MAC's Blacktrack fluidline). I love UD' liquid liner in Ecstasy, which I find super-easy to use. This one seems to be a bit trickier in that I have a harder time getting a thinner line with it than I do with Ecstasy, but it's a great liner. For the price you get a TON of product, and I only need one swipe of the brush for fully-pigmented payoff. Even stopping and starting a line is easy! I would definitely recommend this, and will repurchase if I ever run out!

This is the best liner, and I think I have tried them all. It stays black all day, and unlike other liners, doesnt smudge into the crease of my eyelid. Also, it doesnt turn gray against my eye shadow!! Love Love Love this liner!!

Probably the best eye liner I've used!!! The brush is just firm enough and the size of it gives great application. Only one stroke will give you great results. Really really good stuff

This is great stuff. It is very pigmented and the brush makes it pretty easy to use. It leaves a perfect crisp line each and every time with ease. It also lasts all day without flaking or fading. You also get a truckload of product for what you pay for(making it pretty cheap!)

The only thing that could possibly be a problem with this product is the packaging, it may be somewhat difficult to use up every last drip of the product. -BUT- so far so good, I've had it for 3 months and its still working fine.

I had to buy something after Sephora stopped carrying what I had been using. I like this almost as much. The bottle is a little weird, I can't really wipe off excess, so I use a light hand to apply it. I can create a thick or thin line with it but it does tend toward thicker. The color is very dark, a must for a liquid liner for me. Overall I like it a lot, but will probably try something else when it is out.

I cheated on my MAC fluidline for this, and was sorely disappointed. The brush on this is not tapered, so you either get a thick line or very thin, no in between. The bottle is shaped in a way that I can not wipe off the excess liner from the brush, and when I do creates a mess. It felt heavy on my lid all day. Took too long to dry. Back to my MAC fluidline.

I did love the color - a shiny black eyeliner would be great, just not with this applicator or bottle shape.

ok so i'll make this very easy to read so here is the break down:


PROS:
-rich black
-cute container
-easy application
-long staying power
-no smudging as long as it is dry

CONS:
- i doubt i'll be able to get every drop of liquid with the bottle shape.
-brush is not tappered = no very fine lines
-takes a pretty long time to dry. and if it is only semi dry, it smudges so easily


I put down yes for repurchase, but it is more of a maybe. i'll see how this goes. =)

i quite like this product. i find the brush easy to use. i have pretty small hands so it fits quite nicely. the only thing i dont like is that it is a bit messy around the edge since i like to wipe off excess liner before applying.

i generally use mac blacktrack and blitz n' glitz fluidline, but sometimes i get lazy to use a separate brush... i like that this has it's own applicator that doesn't require me to clean it after every single use.