I really like these eye liners. The tips are soft so it goes on pretty well. I don't like the plastic caps because they tend to break on me so I took off a lippie for packaing. I like the smudger but it could be a little bit softer.
I've gone through 4 of these. I usually use it in the bronze color, it looks softer on me, so it works. I have oily skin, I wear contacts, I rub my eyes, so usually things don't stay on my face for long. This will stay on my eyes for generally the duration of the day, it'll fade but I'd be happy if it stayed on for 6 hours. I like the smudger on the other side. One of these will last me for at least a year, I usually throw it away after a year to prevent contamination. Definitely head over to your lancome counter to try this out. It's soft and it doesn't hurt your skin.
This product never stings my very sensitive lids & eyes; but unfortunately, does not stay on my lids for more than two hours, giving me raccoon eyes. Somehow I have very difficult lids for eyeliners--even the MAC fluidline, Bobbi Brown gel liners didn't stay on my lids.
I've been using this in black/noir for years, although I purchase it on ebay to save some money. I love this when I have to get ready quickly. It does smudge a bit after a few hours if I don't take the time and do my makeup 'right' - where i put powder on my eyelids and under my eyes, then I put a line of shadow under my eyes as well - if I do this, then it doesn't smudge. It's also fantastic when I use it under my Revlon Colorstay liquid liner! These are two products I can't live without!
I use this in smoke to accentuate the gray in my blue eyes. It looks smokey-grey with a touch of blue. I haven't found that exact color anywhere else and am n love with the color. Lasts all day. (It better for that price...haha)
The reason I gave it a three is cuz it can dry up after using it for a few mos, giving a less intense color. For the price, I would want the formula to be more flawless than that. It would still dry up even if I dabbed some water on it or rolled off the top layer b4 applying.
Its creamy but it tends to smudge off and fade quickly for me. i don't like how it only rotates upwards and doesn't go down. I do like the smudger.
Because non-waterproof eyeliner always smudges on me before I can even walk out the door I decided to try this one. In the beginning I thought it worked but now, after a few weeks, it seems to start smudging on me faster and faster. It's as if the quality goes down rapidly over time. It's a shame though cause i really liked it at the start. Definetly will not repurchase, there has to be a better waterproof one out there.
It smudges so horribly. And it's very hard to remove. I'm sure many low-price eyeliners can do much better. I really regret buying it.
I was so disappointed with this eyeliner. It smudged like crazy! The packaging is also terrible. When I accidentally twisted too much, I couldn't get it to go back down. Then when I put the cap back on, it got all smushed in the cap. The plastic cap also cracked pretty soon after I got it. That a waste of money!!!