For the past couple years this has been my favorite eyeliner. I get ebony black.
It goes on smooth and somewhat creamy. However it is a good creamy. I don't have a problem with smudging. It works great for smokey eyes. My sister, mom and I all use this eyeliner.
The only downfall is it wears off and I need to reapply. But no big deal, it reapplies pretty well. I also don't care for the smudging sponge. I never care for those I prefer a Qtip.
For the price, this eyeliner is brilliant. I have had heaps of compliments since I have started wearing this, compared to my beloved Mac eyeliners :-(. It is a bit smudgy, but its a nice smudgy! I have only got it in ebony black so far, but because of the compliments im going to get a brown one as well...
I have this in bronze which is a very nice color for my blue eyes. I like this eyeline because it very pigmented and didn't smudge. The only thing I don't like is I have to sharpen it every time I use it or it pokes my eyes if that makes sense. I recently bought revlon eyeliner and like it better because it lasts longer and I only sharpen it like every few days, but I really liked the color of this maybelline one =(
I actually really liked this! I like creamy eyeliners.
This didn't smear for me, magically.
And it stayed beautifully on my waterline. I was stunned.
This just happened to work for me.
+ it's nice and black :)
It's just not quite perfect though.
This smudges a lot but the pigmentation is very nice in deep black. I don't recommend this but somehow i always end up buying it anyways. Maybe I just have a really watery eye.
CRAP compared to MAC, Stila, Bobbi Brown, etc.
The pigmentation was awful.
I'm a gel liner snob because I absolutely love them and this rates even below HIP for me.
Pay the $7 more for MAC's fluidlines. They have so much more pigmentation and they stay a whole lot better.
This is going back to the store. I don't even have oily eyelids and this was sliding all over.
This was a spur of the moment purchase for me and I don't know what part of it appealed to me because it's a pretty average eyeliner. It's realllly creamy and highly pigmented which is good. But it smudged like hell on me like not in a good way. Oh and it forms quite thick lines even when I tried sharpening it to a point. The only thing I like is the smudger which worked really well for me. Overall it is a good product but just doesn't work with my oily lids.
I have in brown. Very creamy and pigmented. I can only use this on my top lash line. Any place else it immediately smudges and I don't have very oily eyelids. I'll use up but not repurchase.
This product runs out so easily...even though I apply it only once a day. There is no need for the sponge tip smudger-it actually takes a lot of it off. It smudges really well (for a smoky look) and I don't blame my eyeliner for wearing off, I know how to control that with powder or eyeshadow, but for some reason I have very little of it left...I have to sharpen the pencil very often. For someone who needs precise definition or eyelining the waterline, I imagine this liner is not for you either.