i really like this product, its really black stays on my lid pretty well, stays on my waterline foreverr. i use it on my lower lash line lightly and smudge it out and it last all daay !
the only con i have about this product is when i put it on my water line it feels like sticky, its soo uncomfortable, especially when i wear contacts. idk if its because ive had it for over a year , but i really dislike that sticky feeling

I love this eyeliner. it is my go-to when i'm in a rush. It glides on very nicely. I don't necessary think it's worth it buy the full size one for $17 because I have like 30 of the minis from the palettes that Urban Decay has released but I definitely think its a must-have. It does last long on the eyes although i wouldn't necessary say 24 hours lol. The product itself lasts long too so a mini one will carry you for awhile.

I just received a mini size of this liner with a gift set, and i'm so glad I got to try this out! I think i've finally found my black eye liner i've been searching for. Usually eye liners smudge and dry away quickly through out the day, but this liner lasted me all day! It was even abit hard to take off with remover wipes, over all A+++ I will deff. be buying the full size.

The texture is too creamy for my oily lids. It disappears or smudges everywhere after a couple hours, even with UDPP or other primers. It would work great if I wanted that smudgy look but 95% of the time I don't because I'm normally wearing makeup for work. The unintentional smokey eye look just doesn't work for that conservative environment. For the price, it's just not worth the trouble. If I could return it I would, instead it's going in my swap list (check it out!).

I've been wanting to get my hands on this pencil for awhile but since we don't have UD here in my country and they won't ship internationally I was lucky to have this off from Naked Palette which i gave in and got it from ebay. I use Smolder and Engraved from MAC and I can say Zero fits in between those 2. It's soft and easy to apply like Smolder and doesn't smudge and stays on just where i put it for hours, even after 2 hours of sweaty workout session,just like Engraved.And it's veerryy black ! I can't wait to get this in full size !

I have read so much about this product and they were all great reviews. So i went ahead and bought it. And honestly...I dont care much about it. It does not stay on my waterline at all. And on the lid..I dont think it's that dark at all. I like my MAC blacktrack fluid line better.

After reading and hearing rave reviews on this eyeliner that never budges, I bought it in Sephora without even thinking and I do not regret my decision. This eyeliner is my everyday look. It does not budge unless by force that I'm smudging it or taking it off at the end of the day. It may smudge a bit under the outer corners of my eyes, but I don't mind touching it up with a makeup eraser pen. I also use it on the upper inner rim of my eye for a natural look and it's perfect! The color is very pigmented and you can see it very well. The only pet peeve I have about it is that you must use a specific sharpener for it to be sharpened the way it should be.

After trying numerous eyeliners from Chanel to Makeup Forever to cheap drugstore brands like NYC, this is definitely THE best eyeliner I have used. It takes A LOT to make this eyeliner run, and unless my allergies act up (read: watery eyes) I never get those "pigment tears" in the corners of my eyes. If you are using it along your waterline, it helps to keep your eye open for 30 seconds or so to help the eyeliner set. An excellent product from UD, definitely worth the money, I just wish they had a wider selection of colors!

this is my HG eye pencil!!!
i have gone through a TON of eyeliners & have finally found the ONE!
it goes on smooth & soft (no pulling on the lid) and it stays on FOREVER!
i am so glad that i found this eye pencil!
it's a bit pricey but you def get your money's worth in my opinion.
if you don't believe me, go to Sephora & try it on your hand. you'll see that it stays in place until you scrub it off!
loves it! continued >>

I believe this is a fantastic liner. The only one I can think of that would compare is Make Up For Ever's Aqua liner. UD's liner is dark and creamy and easy to use. Keeping it sharp allows for getting in really close to the lash line.I dont understand the reviewers that say they dont like it because it doesnt stay on their waterline. I've never found one that does so i think they're dreaming. That spot will always require touchups no matter what. I love this pencil and will continue to buy again and again.