I'm not a big fan of these liners, but they'll do. I have it in black but when it dries it turns kind of dark grey. I don't wear liquid liner that often so it's fine when I need it. But I don't think I'll repurchase.

This was my first liquid liner, and I found it fairly easy to apply. It's a good one to learn with. I like the short wand; it fits nicely in my hand. The brush tip frayed a little on occasion, but nothing too bad.

As far as the colors go, I wish "black/brown" was darker. It's really just a light brown. "Blackest black" is a true black, the 2nd most black eyeliner I've tried (the first being Wet 'n' Wild Creme Liner). Great for evening looks.

The best thing this eyeliner has going for it is its staying power; it doesn't budge. I wore it during an outdoor concert recently, and since this is Texas, it was 100 degrees and I was sweating all over the place, but my eyeliner stayed in place!

I never used to use eye line but, this makes it easy to apply and it stays on. I only use it on my top lashes. I tight line with this in the very black/ black color for an everyday look. My eyelashes are black but are very straight and you really can't see them. This really makes them pop. I can adjust the thickness or thinness of the line depending on the look I am going for. I usually get these BOGO so the price is very cheap (Normally about$6-7 USD for two). This is HG for me, I don't really see a need to try any more expensive liners. I also like the color stay pencil liner but, it tends to fade and offer a more dramatic look than I need for every day and the liquid version last 14hrs + without any touch ups.

This is definitely my HG Liquid Eyeliner!
It stays put, doesn't smudge and is seriously just an all round great liquid liner. I just recently started using liquid liner at school instead of pencil and people have been coming up to me saying how pretty my eyes look!

I will definitely re-purchase without a doubt!

I did not like this eyeliner. I am good with applying gel and liquid liners but I had a difficult time using this product. It also burned my skin. I really wanted to love this because it does not budge. However, in the end after multiple attempts, I could not make this eyeliner work me.

Very nice liquid liner. It stays put, and doesn't smudge or rub off on my upper or lower lids (this is key - no racoon eyes!).

When the liner fluid is almost out and the well dries up considerably; i.e., the'res a little pigment left if you scrape around the well, or the applicator tip still paints lightly, but its no longer really liquid, I find that it works well to fill in brows. The effect when used this way is somewhere between a pencil and a powder filler - very feathery and subtle, but precise and still "colorstay" :)

I love this liquid liner.
I had only used liquid liner once before, but couldn't do it at all. It was messy & hard to control.
I love this felt tip. It makes it so much easier to control and my lines go on straight.
It doesn't flake or smear at all.
I got it in blackest black & it was very black. Just what I was looking for.
I'm very satisfied with this product and will definately be buying again. continued >>

a pretty good liquid liner
it doesnt budge (Y) which is good and the hard short tip i think gives more control

definitely buy again

Absolute HG. I've tried it all - L'Oreal's Lineur Intense, Maybelline's Ultra Liner, Shiseido's Liquid Liner, Prestige's - this is it. I use this in black-brown to be a little less harsh than black (though honestly, no one can tell the difference except me) and have repurchased this at least 8 times. It stays on all day, is truly waterproof and flake-proof. I can cry in this, no problem. It's matte but not dry-looking, as some liquid liners can look. The brush is so easy to use, a pointed, cone-shaped felt tip. And the price is right. Love, love, love.

One tip, though - don't get this at a drugstore that doesn't have high turnover. The fresher the better because these last a long time, but once it hits a certain point (for me it's somewhere between 4-6 months), the formula seems to dry out and you may start getting flakiness. That's when I know to throw it out and get a new one.

I love this liquid eyeliner! I have worn liquid eyeliner for about 4 years now so i have tried my fair share and out of all the drugstore/high end brands i have tried this one is my favorite! It stays through the night no matter what im doing and despite the weather without creasing or smudging at all and it gives a nice satin looking finish unlike others. It also glides on extremely even and smooth.