MAC paint pots are so hit and miss for me. I really wanted to love this product as it is such s beautiful, unique color when swatched on my arm. But as soon as I put it on my eyelid to blend it out, it just dissapears! It leaves a faint gold glitter behind but not the gorgeous rosey gold color like in the pot. Even when layered, it still doesn't show up as more than a bit of glitter.
The color of this paint pot is just gorgeous! Whole reason why I got it really and was surprised (because I've never used a paint pot, let alone MAC) at the way it applies. Goes on smoothly like butter. I've had no problems with it applying patchy. The color is amazing in the pot and out. I would definitely buy again, but I don't see myself running out of this anytime soon XD there's a LOT of product here, another plus.
I've noticed that some reviewers say this applies patchy, but I've never had that problem. I always use TFSI first, then two THIN layers of Rubenesque, and I've never had a problem! Looks lovely all by itself on my brown eyes, or makes an awesome base for orange, peachy-pink (like MAC Expensive Pink), or melon colored shadows!
I think this is a beautiful color on it's own, it's not a primer like Painterly, for green eyes. It is Bare Study but strong peach, not dark just peach, instead of champagne as Bare Study. I am suprised it does not have better reveiws. Its MUCH lighter than pictures show on the computer screen and it is not at all glittery but certainly not matte. Just on the lid is perfect.
I love MAC's Paint Pots, and I tend to use them as a shadow more so than as a base for other shadows. Rubenesque has an orangey, golden color to it which is perfectly suited for warm-toned people. This has good staying power, if used with a primer. A perfect dupe for it in another line is Urban Decay's X eyeshadow. Although X comes in loose pigment and pressed shadow form, it is identical to this color.
This is a beautiful pink golden peach color in the pot. On my NC20-25 asian skin tone it transfers more golden and can sometimes look a tad too orangey during the winter when I don't have a tan. However I tend to wear this in the summer and it looks amazing! Beautiful consistency and is very creamy. Has golden shimmer throughout it and is sheer, but can be built up a bit. I prefer to wear this alone or layered under eyeshadows. Either way though you definitely need a primer under this because it creased on me within 3 hours. Then again all of the Mac pain pots do, and I do not have oily lids. UDPP alone will keep my eyeshadows from creasing. Eyeshadows are relatively easy to blend over this. Has lasted me a long time and I still have a lot of product left. Overall a great product and a definite repurchase! Spring/summer is almost here in SoCal and I can't wai to bust this out again.
I was so excited to try out this product. I even checked reviews and swatches before purchasing it. At the MAC store, a very kind MUA swatched it on the back of my hand and i was totally sold in 1 sec... i bought it. As soon as i got home i decided to apply some of that beauty on my eyes. But alas...! The consistency was a bit weird... or should i say tricky? The product didn't seem even at all, it also looked patchy and flaky. So i decided to use a brush instead of my fingers... to come out with the same result. Then i decided to use a spongetip aplicator... same result. Then i decided to follow a tip i read somewhere about this paintpot... which basically is layering the product... to wait for each layer to set and then to go over it again. Sadly i got the same result but now with better color payoff, however the flaking effect was even more noticeable which also made my upper eyelids look kinda old and wrinkly!!!! Sigh... the product in the pot looks so gorgeous, i really wanted it to work but it did not... no matter how i tried to use it. And well, to be honest, for a product above 15 dls i am expecting it to work as it is intended to. Not to use a million tricks to make it work.
In the end i exchanged it for a Fix + and i went back home happier but still letting out a sigh about that beauty that looked too good to be true :( I am giving it 2 lippies because of the packaging and the color itself, but those are the only good things about it.
As the other reviewers have mentioned, this is absolutely gorgeous in the pot, its a golden pinky/peach color. The color reminds me a lot of Nars' orgasm lipgloss and blush. On my lids, its a pretty golden tint with hints of pink. I love the paint pot formulation for its staying power and its defence against creasing. I can see this color as working really well with tanned and warm toned skin. I wore this often with Cover Girls' country woods eyeshadows and it looked great, and changed the depth of rubenesque. Noting other review's advise about these drying out, I'm keeping them upside down in my organizer.
I was disappointed. This product was supposed to be a great base product, but it's a bit tricky to apply and the result was pretty uneven and flaky. Besides it didn't last all day but started to crease after a couple of hours. Also the color is a bit too orange for me. I noticed that you really need to close the pot properly or it totally dries out, as mine did after a couple of months.
This is a go to product for lazy people!
If you don't have time to do your detailed makeup just smudge a bit of this on your eyelids.
Blend a little with Buck or Smog from the Naked Palette on the crease area, add some mascara and a bit of smudged eyeliner and you're done!
Good staying power, and comes in a cute little glass jar pot. It also lasts you a long time (I've used it for three weeks now and I haven't even made a dent).
Definitely worth a try, guys :)