Picked this up today while passing through my local Walgreens. This is totally crap. Got black black and dark brown. The black doesn't even show up on my waterline, nor does it grab onto the eye. Not to mention it almost comes off as a grayish color. Now the dark brown on the other hand, is okay for filling the same areas of the brow, up that's about it. Thank goodness it was on sale for 70 cents. Most definitely won't purchase this liner ever again.......blah!!!!
Well... i just bought it today (March 30th, 2009)
and i used it when i got home, and the packaging was ok, it wasnt too flashy, or complicated.
it was ok for me, (Just getting into the makeup world.)
overall, its ok.
I will say that I'm a firm believer that drugstore black eyeliner is just as good if not better than designer eyeliner, and for the price, you can't complain. I typically use NYC black eyeliner, but seeing as for some reason that's difficult to find, I settled on this one when I was desperate. It's decent, although if you have even slightly oily skin it wil tend to... not smear, but sort of disappear, leaving only traces of it on your eye. You may have to apply it a few times over the course of the day/evening, but it goes on rather thick and is easy to work with.
So this is a dirt cheap product which I understand. I bought it in a pinch, but would not buy it again. It doesn't look black at all. It goes on in a grayish tone (at least on me). The stick is really long and akward to store and use. At least I am not out 10 or more dollars for this... just 99 cents.
its a decent khol pencil for the price it can be used for smokey eye effect as its smudegable and cheap you cant go wrong for the price. My only gripe is the pencil is too long and cumbersome to bring in my bag
eh, this eyeliner is just not very good. yeah its cheap and you get a ton of product but the pigment is not good, its not a true black. its not very easy to apply either, when i try to line my waterline i feel like i have to tug and press way too much to get any color to show up. wont repurchase...
to be honest, this stuff is bad. doesnt have the best pigmentation, doesnt appear too black for me at all. prob wudnt buy uit again
I don't wear a lot of eyeliner, so I bought this because it was only like $.99, and I knew the pencil would last forever. It didn't smudge at all, and lasted fairly long on the waterline. Easy and smooth to apply, but kind of difficult to sharpen. That could be my fault though, I might just need a new sharpener. I'd say this is a great pencil liner.
I've been using this eyeliner on and off for the past few years and it's pretty consistent. Nice color, sure it has it's problems but it looks great, stays on. And for a little above a dollar what could go wrong. Definitely worth it if you use black eyeliner like me every day. Doesn't scratch it's a nice creamy formula. I recommend it to everyone who asks me for black eyeliner.
This pencil black eyeliner worked very well for it's price (I mean, for a $1, what could go wrong?). I was very impressed by how this glided on nicely (not exactly smooth, but I didn't scratch my lash line in order to get it on) and the color is fine. Would recommend to anyone that's looking for a decent, cheap, drugstore eyeliner.