love this eyeliner!!! goes on super smooth, almost creamy. awesome staying power as well. great value for money....it's my go-to black liner!

Terrible eyeliner. You have to litreally drag it across your eye and no colour comes out. Dont buy it.

Yay: Easy to use, lasts all day
Nay: Don't get on clothes. Or carpets, for that matter. And yes, I've done both
My friend bought me one as part of a set for my birthday a couple of years ago, and since then, I haven't bought any other felt-tip eyeliner. It's easy to use, lasts all day, and is is easy to remove. I'm forever recommending it, especially to those who want to try a liquid eyeliner, but worry they don't have a steady enough hand.

This was a little too dry. I had to draw the line in lots of short strokes, making it look wobbly. Probably a good product for those just starting out with liquid liner, but not comfortable in a more practiced hand: you can't work quickly or confidently as it drags too much. Staying power is fine, there's no flaking or smudging, but I wasn't blown away. Good value for the price, but I've bought Mac's Penultimate Liner to replace it as my "portable" liner.

well... it is an ok liner.. not as black as the penultimeye by MAC, doesn't dry to a even glossy finish like the L'Oreal liner, and not lond wearing like the Shu Uemura liqiud liner or the Illamasqua cake liner.. but it won't ber fair to compare with the high end products so in comparison with the l'Oreal one, i think L'Oreal will be the winner even though i prefer the pen like packaging..

LOVE IT LOVE IT LOVE IT! it is the best liquid eyeliner i have ever tried and it lasts for so long! the felt tip is firm and it helps to get that right line.

i have no idea if this sells in the US anymore. if anybody knows where they sell bourjois products in the US please tell me!

Just bought this as i had run out of my usual liquid eyeliner as i wanted to try something new. Based on first impressions i am really liking this eyeliner. I love the fact its like a felt tip pen it makes applying alot easier and more practical. It lasts all day and is an intense black which i really like, its also really practical for carrying around in ur makeup or travel bag as it is thin and long! i recommend this to people who find applying eyeliner tricky.

This product lasts for HOURS. I had it on from morning till midnight and when I went home, my eyeliner was still in place. No smudges and what I love about it is that it is really very easy to apply. It goes on really easily and even though I usually can't draw a straight line, I was able to with this.

However, one downside is that the liquid inside doesn't flow properly. When I first used it, it bled and I had a lot of eyeliner on one eye. And when I used it on the other eye, I couldn't get the ink to come out? There was like no ink left and I thought the eyeliner dried up.. Was quite disappointed. Then I left it standing up ( with pen tip facing downwards) and the next day, there was ink again. But I feel that the ink is always not regulated. And sometimes the pen will feel really dry that it is hard to apply.

I wish something could be done about that. otherwise, i really love it for its easy application and long-lasting-ness.

I bought this by accident, didn't realise it was a felt pen liner (don't ask how I didnt clock on)...Now i'm on my third, and ive been converted to the wonders of liquid eyeliner.
Goes on well, looks good (FAR better than max factor) lasts ages, good product for a reasonable price!

This eyeliner gives you a crisp line without messy bleeding and is easy to control and use, because of it's convenient pen style. (What can I say, I love pens!). It gives you a comparatively thick line compared to some others out there so it's your choice on whether you're going for that convenience of not having to obsessively thicken your line for twice as long or not. In truth it costs more than the one that Physician's Formula has but what can I say, I'm a slight packaging nut and the Bourjois range is always so pretty, with this pen looking simple and sleek but doesn't look like a supermarket permanent pen like the Physician's Formula one. Unless I'm hearing some incredible reviews about the Shiseido eye liner pen (which can use refills unlike the Bourjois one) I'm going to stick with this.