The only reason I bought this was because of the cute little package, anyone that knows me know that I loveeee animal print however, I do not like this product much. I already have long eye lashes and this does not do anything for them they still look the same even after applying. I will not buy again and I love the other maybelline macaras such as falsies, mega plush, rocket, and great lash.

I was really attracted to this product by the cute little bottle. I liked the leopard print labeling on it and I picked it up after it caught my eye. I thought this would be a really nice mascara but that wasn't the case. I was excited to try this when I got it, but it didn't excite me after I put not even one coat on. This did NOTHING for my lashes. I have long, straight, thin lashes and they drooped like crazy after I curled them and applied this. It didn't add any length or volume it kind of just sat on my lashes. Needless to say, I have not used it since and I will not repurchase. Nice packaging though, ha.

I liked the original Colossal so when the Cat Eyes came out I decided to try it in waterproof (to be honest I got suckered in by the cute animal print packaging).

Pros:
-Holds a decent curl,
-Gives some length

Cons:
-Makes lashes more spiky than cat eye
-Doesn't give much volume

Tips: This is an ok mascara. I like to use it on my bottom lashes, because it makes them look longer without making them look spidery.

this is my first waterproof mascara. since the mascara is new to me, ive only gotten to use it indoors, havent put it to the rain test yet. i do very much like the black gel consistency of the formula. it goes on nice and smoothly. i do really like the curved brush. i can use the brush right side up, or upside down and either way its great. what i particularily like about the curved brush is that the emphasis is on elongating my outter lashes...hence the cat eye effect. the lashes are great on almond shaped eyes...i get where the cat idea is coming from.
i would re purchase this product. i worked at macys in the cosmetics dept for a while so i have gotten to use high end $$ dept store mascaras. i feel i have enuf experience with them so i know what im looking for now. its all about the brush, ladies. the brush is what makes or breaks it, along with the formula type.

I am always looking for a better mascara. My job keeps my eyes closed a lot so any mascara usually ends up smearing or flaking under my eyes bringing out my bags.
I also have very long, straight, but sparse lashes. No volume formula can ever make it look like I have lashes, so all things considered this formula does a decent job for the money.
At first I didn't like the curved wand, but now that I've gotten used to it I do. (I wouldn't go out of my way for it though)
Overall, decent for the money.

The animal print on the package suckered me into buying this mascara... i dont like it too much... it makes my eyelashes clumpy and it irrates my eyes on a regular basis

It seems I always LOVE the mascara others hate, hahaah(;
But anyways, I've been looking for the cat eyes effect forever now and this is it! My only complaint is that I wish my lashes looked thicker, but I can overlook that! This makes your lashes so separated and long and I love them! Plus the packaging is ADORABLE. I have this in washable, as waterproof always bothers my contacts for some reason.

Love this, curls beautifully doesnt irritate eyes! quick and easy to apply. Makes lashes look great.

This mascara is a fail. The adorable animal-print packaging suckered me in. The mascara itself (I bought in in waterproof) is very wet and makes my already thin eyelashes spidery and doesn't deliver the promised "cat eye" results. The wand is also very cheap-looking. Won't repurchase.

I love this mascara. It actually does deliver cat eyes to me. It depends on how you apply it.
I always bend my lashes with the brush when I apply it, and keep them bent for 15 seconds.
It works good on my lashes. Then I also do that with the outer corner of my lashes.
I like the lasting power of this. My lashes look good throughout the day and it doesn't flake.
The package is also great, it's the only thing in my makeup box that's easy to find : )
I will definitely repurchase this.