I absolutely love this mascara! I have been using my Benefit They're Real and Clinique High Impact mascara together for the longest time to give me my favorite, go to look. Recently I started using this mascara by Maybelline and fell in love. It gives me the same look for a fraction of the price. Definitely a repurchase.
I love this mascara! I don't experience any of these mentioned flaws, other than a slight odd smell. I never get clumps or flakes, and it makes my lashes so long! Love this and definitely want to get the waterproof version for summer. Best mascara I've had.
This stuff is amazing!!! I bought this because it was on sale and the brush interested me. I honestly didn't think that this is going to be that good, until I put it on! The wand brushes out any clumps, hold the curl perfectly (it might be because I use the waterproof version),makes it fuller,and volumizes!! Everything I could want in a mascara!!
My favourite mascara! It lengthens, thickens and it last quite long. Love the brush! Lashes look great without putting a lot of effort in when applying. I have received tons of complements when wearing this mascara and some people actually asked me if these are my own lashes or whether I have extensions :D
I really like the way this mascara applies -- it goes on smoothly, it gives me volume, and it looks good. The bad thing about this is its staying power. When I apply it in the morning, by the afternoon I already have flakes all around my eyes area. I even use a mascara primer! This mascara flakes off and by the evening, it looks like I've slept all day and rubbed by eye makeup off. EDIT: I forgot to mention that this product has the worst smell. It smells like a classroom and can be a major turnoff.
Every time I apply my eye make up I feel like I have something in my eye. I thought it was my eye shadow that was doing this so I was really tapping off my brush before applying and still, within a minute, I had that fleck of something stuck in my eye feeling. It would literally drive me crazy because the irritation was so annoying to deal with all day long. I began to wonder if it was my mascara, which was Maybelline Volume Express One by One, because I was noticing I always had flakes under my eyes of mascara throughout the day that I was contantly having to wipe away. So it made sense that those flakes were also making into my eyes. I changed mascaras and what do you know, no gunk in my eye feeling anymore. So it was the Maybelline mascara that was messing with my eyes.
Also, I would have to say that the application wasn't anything to write home about. I mean, it was okay. But I never felt like "WOW!" after I applied this mascara. It didn't make my lashes pretty or look that much fuller. It was so so.
I had to buy two of these to get a decent price, and I was so sure I was going to like it based on a review I read in a magazine (I know, I should have learned by now), so I went for it. First, it is very heavy, so it weighs down my lashes. It also clumps. But the reason for my low rating is it flakes like crazy. The flakes got in my eyes, and it hurt! Oh well. So I have a second, unopened one but I wouldn't subject anyone else to it.
I like this a lot. Very lengthening, not too wet or too dry.
okay for bottom lashes
doesn't smudge, minimal flaking
doesn't hold a curl
really heavy formula and a lot gathers at the tips, making my lashes tilt sideways......
not a lot of length or volume
groups my lashes together
One of my least favourite maybelline mascaras. Even with my shiseido nourishing mascara base, it still wouldn't hold a curl and it just looked weird tilting sideways. But I'm Asian and I have a white friend that really likes this. Works better on thicker lashes I think, it wouldn't tilt as much. I'll probably just use this for my bottom lashes and I'll keep the brush. And it has a rosey wine smell, which I don't really care about.
I would definitely say this is by far the best mascara I have tried! It makes your lashes look longer and thicker without being suuuuper clumpy