I bought this in black. This is an awesome liquid eyeliner. This product makes applying liquid eyeliner so freaking easy, thanks to the hard tip it has. It's almost like an eyeliner pen. This is my first liquid eyeliner and I didn't need practice to get a good line with a wing at the ends. Packaging aside, the product itself is awesome! This thing wouldn't budge or smudge. It isn't runny or too thick or whatever. BUT, this removes soo easily with water. That may be a good thing, as in I don't need to spend 10 mins removing it. However, if I have wet hands and I accidentally touch my eye, it will smudge. That said, it wouldn't smudge as long as it doesn't get on contact with water.


Ok, pros aside. This eyeliner only lasts for 6 months!! It has 6M written on the packaging which means once you open it, you need to dispose it after 6 months of using. That really sucks considering most eyeliners last up to 2 years (24M). This product would have been HG for me if not for the 6M. Because then it's a pain just like mascara. I would have repurchase if not for the 6M. I'm sure there are better eyeliners out there that has 24M and works just as great as this eyeliner. I would repurchase if I couldn't find a better eyeliner though.

great liquid eyeliner, sturdy hard point, easy to use, lasts long..loves it!!!! will always buy...

I have this eyeliner in shade 2, which is a pretty dark brown color. It’s very easy to use and the staying power is excellent. I would recommend this to anybody who’s new to liquid eyeliners. I’ve had this eyeliner for over a year and it still works perfectly. It didn’t dry out or anything which is pretty amazing. I think I’ll purchase another one in black next time I’m at The Body Shop. It’s one of the only makeup products of theirs that I actually like.

Bought this in the darker brown (forgot the name), there are three shades I think... anyhow, the quality is reasonable for its price. I find it works quite well actually.

1. It is relatively easy to apply, I was a first time liquid liner user (so prolly practice makes perfect?). The applicator is quite fine and a thin line is achievable.
2. It dries quite fast, so no worries there about it getting all over the place.

As of now I can't think of anything that's seriously wrong or bad about this product... if I do I'll definitely do an update!

It hurts when I apply it for the first few times. The black will also fade off when it's dry. I tend to tear when I yawn, my tear will wet the eyeliner and smudge on me.

However, I love it because its easy to apply and it goes off easily with water. Doesnt give me a hassle to remove it.

This reviews goes to TBS metallic liquid eyeliner in gold. I purchased this at discounted price. I'm so grateful that I didn't miss this. I use this liner on my waterline and the gold brightens my eyes in some magical way. The applicator is easy to control and the liner stay put all day.

FYI: the gold is pretty much similar to MAC pigment in old gold, only this is not glittery. It produces true metallic gold.

Definitely will repurchase

I love wearing liquid eyeliner all around the rim of my eye followed by the MAC smoulder eye pencil.. LOVE!!!! this liquid eyeliner..it stays and yet washes off easily with water. I got it in black... and it looks matte with I love!

The liquid eyeliner runs! It smudges even when it's liquid! I was quite shocked. -_-
Yes, easy to remove but i dont want to look like a panda everytime i use it!

this is a great eyeliner. my friend got it before me and i loved it so i got one for myself. the price wasnt bad either. i got the colour that is dark brown but when it goes on it looks black. i like the applicator becuse its firm and it gives you control. you can make the line thick or thin, i like it thin and natural. it comes off prtty well i usually take a shower and when i come out its gone. its a very good eyeliner and i like how it can stand on its own.

This is a long-lasting eyeliner that I have in the Brown shade. I've lined my top lid with it and it has looked extremely natural. The felt tipped applicator is firm and gives extremely good control. Best applicator in a liquid liner ever. I always find it hard, with brush applicators, to get a straight line because the brush always accidentally gets caught in my eyelashes. The felt tipped applicator gives excellent precision and is less likely to touch your eyelashes and go all over the place. I can't think of anything to improve on this product.


UPDATE 02/06/08: This gives an awesome cats eye look, because it's so controllable. I can make precise shapes around my eye and it looks perfect! I'm more in love with this than I was originally. Also now that I have lighter hair, the eyeliner looks darker on me. Before, when I had black hair, the eyeliner looked true to colour - dark brown - and wasn't particularly vibrant on me. So I would recommend the dark brown as a more-natural-than-black black for people with light hair :]]] continued >>