This is very good for a liquid liner- it stays on quite well compared to other kinds I've tried, and is easier to use than gel liner with a brush. It does flake off a bit on the corners, but still performs better than any other liquid I've tried.

This eyeliner is amazing!! HG product! The felt tip is SO precise and gentle. You can draw the smallest most light line, or press harder and draw a thicker line. It's the best applicator I've ever seen. It dries very quickly so have q-tips on hand if you usually make mistakes. It is definitely waterproof, it won't come off without makeup remover. Though, recently I used it down south and it takes a little while longer to dry in the humidity, and sunscreen makes it smudge (might be the oil in the sunscreen). Definitely the best eyeliner I've ever used though. You can try it at Sephora if you're not sure about it. It's pretty expensive, about 30$ (Canada).. but I would say it's worth it. You could always order online or buy it in the States!

Absolutely amazing product. Really makes it easy to line the eyes with the fine-tipped felt applicator. Color does last all day and is easy to remove.

My absolute favourite eyeliner in the world, dark black and glossy and goes on super sleek and stays on all day. Absolutely amazing. my HG for sure.

Amazing eyeliner. I work in a cosmetic store that sells Stila and I always recommend this eyeliner to anyone looking for a liquid liner. Especailly people who are new to applying line because the felt tip point makes it easy to press on the side and get the perfect straight line. It stays on perfectly the whole day, no smudging.

Tried this eyeliner in both black and white. My verdict... it's my HG for eyeliners because it stays true to it's name, it actually stays all day! :) The only bad thing about this product is that it's really expensive $28.00 at Sephora and the product dries up quick. It only lasted me around 3 months before I had to repurchase. That's the only reason why I'm giving it 4 stars. Will I repurchase? Yes! It's a bit of a splurge but you know what...It's really worth it. The eyeliner goes on really dark for the black one and the precision tip makes it easy to do the perfect cat eyes and thin lines for an everyday look.

This eyeliner is really great for a newbie. I love that it has a brush-like tip which makes it easy to draw thin to thick lines. The pen is easy to hold and and comfortable to use. I got this in BLACK and it is very dark. This liner stays put! If you don't remove it with eye-makeup remover, you will wake up with it intact the next day.

My main issue with it is it sometimes leaves a bit of a shine. I prefer a matte black liner. This is why I gave it a four and why I won't buy it again.

Stay All Day Eyeliner is true to the title, it really does stay all day! Super easy to apply, I love that the tip is firm, it's pretty hard to mess it up!

i really wanted to like this! it goes on smooth, i love the glossy black and it's easy to use.

but for some weird reason when i use this to do my usual cat-eye, the 'flick' part on my right eye ALWAYS flakes off. i don't know why. it's always the right side. it's annoying. i've been using this for about three weeks and i don't understand why this keeps happening.

This is by far the best liquid eyeliner I've used so far! My lids are really oily and I often get raccoon eyes if I don't use the right products (eyeliners). I've tried a number of waterproof eyeliners and I must say that Stila All Day Waterproof is the best among them! It's super easy to use- take note, I'm not a make-up kinda girl but I found this one really easy to apply. Will definitely purchase again!