This one's a keeper... first of all, love the packaging, it's very cool and feels sturdy. The product itself is a lot dryer than the other mascaras that I own, which i initially was skeptical about, but it's a great lengthening mascara, if you have short and stubby lashes like me, this one works! It does clump a bit, but not too bad. It's the most lengthening mascara i have tried so far, doesn't give as much volume as the falsies or L'oreal voluminus, but more length for sure. :-)

Three words: ALL OVER FACE!!!
Worn this for three weeks now and it's going in the bin.

My HG drugstore mascara! Doesn't clump, gives volume, super long lashes, holds a curl all day, doesn't smudge. And you can't beat the price! I use the blackest black. The only thing that would make it perfect would be a little more thickness. I am being super picky here though.

This does not hold a curl, is too thin, makes lashes stick together so that it looks like I have 6 spiky ugly brittle lashes. It is soooo hard to get off and really makes my lashes dry and fall out. HORRIBLE!

Truthfully this is one of the worst mascaras I've purchased- ever.
It feels thick, looks chunky, flakes like crazy, and makes my eyelashes shed at a faster rate. I generally like my brush to be more of a scoop shape, but I wanted to try this odd brush. Curiosity killed the lash.
The shape wasn't the worst thing. The material the brush is made out of is incredibly harsh, the consistency is thick, like beyond "volumizing thick"... Gross.
It flakes, but it stays on- in a bad way. Even with professional eye makeup remover it's still tough to get off- this is where lashes are lost.

Luckily I've found many more that I thoroughly enjoy. Loracs multiplex 3d lashes... Amazing, dramatic, beautiful.
Urban decays new curling mascara is also amazing.
They are both clearly quality products. I very highly reccomend either one.

I liked the curled wand of this mascara. I felt like it gave my lashes some lift. It defined my lashes pretty well and gave me some volume but I noticed that it got clumpy on my pretty easily. I also felt like it didn't hold a curl as well as some other waterproof mascaras. Smudging wasn't really a problem. Overall an average mascara. Nothing special.

Decent mascara, it definitely lengthens ad volumizes, but it clumps after more than a few coats. If you already have very volumized lashes, I don't recommend this. It's also very, very black which is a plus for me. Definitely a dramatic mascara.

A very decent product. It lenghts and adds volume. No smudging during day. Nice product but i´m looking for something more dramatic and noticeable. I think i come back with L´oreal voluminous full definition.

i hate this Mascara i found it weak and watery and it didnt make my lashes long and thick how i like them. it takes 10 coats just to make my lashes look decent NEVER AGAIN I HAVE LOST ALL HOPE IN MAYBELLINE PRODUCTS :(

This product makes the lashes look dry, brittle, and spidery. It is a bit waterproof, but I still smudge towards the end of the day. WIll not repurchase.