This pencil has made my eyes itch. I notice it later on at night. It had never happened before. Hopefully maybelline will reimburse

I just started wearing makeup and I decided to buy this as my first eye liner. Badddd choicee! It smudges like craaaazy. It smudges under my eye, on my eyelid and sometimes not even near my eye. Oh! And when you sharpen it, it doesnt really sharpen it's like sharpening a color pencil. ):

smudgy smudgy! this smudges like crazy and i dont even have oily lids or anything! it always gets below my eyes and fades.
Pros
Creamy application
spongy smudger
true color

cons
not long lasting at all
smudges quickly

I picked up two of these in sapphire and brown black randomly when they were on sale for $3.99 CAN. Overall, I really like these eyeliners. The staying power isn't the best, but it lasts longer than some of my other eye liners do, and it doesn't flake, even after a full day of wearing it. This doesn't irritate my eyes either (I wear contacts) which is a plus. I really like the smudge brush on the other end of the liner. I use it to smudge the liner after I put it on my lower lashes so that it's not as intense, and it works quite well for that. Overall, a decent eyeliner, and if you can find it on sale, I would definitely recommend it.

This eyeliner worked pretty well for me! And I usually don't have much luck with eyeliner. However, this one glided on pretty well and blended nicely. But it does fade throughout the day. The only thing I really don't like about it is that the smudging sponge isn't very good. My finger works MUCH better. But, I would recommend this!

This eyeliner is OK. I for this in charcoal grey. It goes on somewhat chalky and the pencil is small. Definatley not the best.

I bought this eyeliner because the one I normally use was sold out. I thought I would be adventurous and go for this. I don't mind it. I find it goes on easily and is creamy, however, it does smudge a lot and I find myself having to put it back on throughout the day. Overall, not a bad eyeliner for the price.

this is a great dark pencil liner for the waterline. i wear liquid for the upper lid, so this product works fine for me however if i were to apply it on my upper lid it would smudge horribly so overall it isnt an amazing liner but for me, it does the job i need it too.

For the past couple years this has been my favorite eyeliner. I get ebony black.

PROS:
It goes on smooth and somewhat creamy. However it is a good creamy. I don't have a problem with smudging. It works great for smokey eyes. My sister, mom and I all use this eyeliner.

CONS:
The only downfall is it wears off and I need to reapply. But no big deal, it reapplies pretty well. I also don't care for the smudging sponge. I never care for those I prefer a Qtip.

For the price, this eyeliner is brilliant. I have had heaps of compliments since I have started wearing this, compared to my beloved Mac eyeliners :-(. It is a bit smudgy, but its a nice smudgy! I have only got it in ebony black so far, but because of the compliments im going to get a brown one as well...