Not sure why this is getting so many bad reviews, I think it's one of the better eye make up removers I've used, for this price. I find that it is gentle on my eyes and not greasy, which I like. I wear non-waterproof DIorshow mascara, and occasionally eyeshadow or creme eyeliner. This works like a charm on the liner and shadow. For the mascara, I let the cotton pad sit on my eye for a couple seconds before wiping and it works fine. I did notice that they changed the formula of this sometime this year- maybe around Jan. '09. The old formula had an oily part and a non-oily part and you had to shake it. That one was super greasy. The new formula works just as well as the old formula but isn't greasy. The price is good, I think it's around $8 per bottle and one bottle lasts me several months with semi-regular use.
This is a mediocre eye makeup remover, but is the one I'm currently using. I have to go back and swipe over my eyelids quite a few times to remove my makeup and still in the morning when I was my face again, there is more eye makeup.
I plan on not buying this again after I use it up.
good thing i didnt buy this product becasue it is the worst makeup remover ive ever used! i was hanging out in the sephora store with my friends trying on makeup, and i wanted to try a foundation on my face, but i already had too much on. so i used this makeup remover that they have there next to ever mirror and OMG! it completely burned my face! it gave me red burning scales on my cheeks and around my eyes. the sephora people thought i used alcohol, and i didnt becuase a couple months later i thought maybe it didnt work because my skin was dry, so a couple months later i tried it again and the same thing happend ! this has never happend to me before so i dont know, mabe im allergic to something in it
I really like hanging out in the Sephora store and I like a lot of their products. That being said, this is not a good one. It didnt remove my waterproof eyliner or even the non waterproof mascara. I was totally disappointed with this. I wouldn't recommend this to anyone.
This product cant remove even non waterproof mascara and it stings my eyes as well. A total waste of my money.
I thought I'd give this a shot and boy am I sorry I did. This was terrible. I typicaly wear a lot of browns, but nothing super dark. I might as well have thrown water on my eyes, it barely took anything off. I usually have to get the cotton pad wet 3 or 4 times to feel like something came off. More than once I had to use Vasoline to remove the rest of my makeup, this was not a good product for me..I had better luck with Clinique removers or even the Mary Kay was better than this. Will not buy again.
I was on vacation in Las Vegas and forgot my eye make up remover so i went to the sephora close by and bought a bottle of this. BIG MISTAKE! this stuff is terrible, i bought the smallest size and thank god for that. Just water can get eye make up of better than this. I rubbed and rubbed and rubbed and still my mac fluidline would not come off, don't even get me started on my waterproof mascara. Save your money and buy neutrogena oil free eye makeup remover instead, it's the same price, you get more, and it's a gajillion times better
Bought this because I wasn't in the mood to find something at the drugstore...wish I had been though, because this product isn't so good. It takes off my usual eye makeup (non-waterproof mascara and white eyeliner), but it stings a little bit and it also gives me tiny bumps around my eye...at least one of them turned into a zit. :( Packaging sucks too, it needs a pump or a smaller opening. I will comparison-shop at the drugstore next time, but for now, using gentle hand soap works just as well and doesn't give me bumps. Not a repurchase.
This is the worst eye make-up remover ever. I don't know if I even consider it an eye make-up remover, since it absolutely did not wipe off any of my eye make-up. Extremely disappointed. Won't be buying it again.
Wasn't the worst, but also wasn't the best eye make-up remover I've used over the years. Removes about 50 of eye make-up (liner, mascara, shadow) on the first sweep, but after the initial clean there is still alot left to be removed, especially liner. This *never* removes liner, and I mean regular, not waterproof. I need to use at least two soaked cotton pads and then try and get the rest off with my cleanser. Good because it doesn't leave greasy residue like the more popular bi-phase removers, I would have actually given this a higher rating if it didn't sting the hell out of my eyes.