All in all this was a good eyeliner. The only thing is that you really need a steady hand with it. It also has really good staying power on semi-oily lids. It is a little on the expensive side for the amount you get but a little goes a long way. A distant second in my book. BB Gel eyeliners are number 1 for me.
Personally, I love the look of liquid liner, especially with dramatic red lips and subtle eyeshadow. Artliners work the best for me. The point is fine, making the line more precise. "Brown" looks more like a darker brown on my MMM skin/dark eyes--it's a great alternative to black and since I dont like wearing harsh black liquid liner, this one will probably become a staple. The line doesn't crack (or it hasn't yet) but I have really oily lids.