I tried YR 'Eye Make Up Remover with Chamomile' (you know, the one in the blue bottle) on both waterproof and non-waterproof mascaras; all it removed was a lot of eyelashes - ouch! It did a decent job of washing off my powder e/s and eye brow pencil, but hey, so does soap and water. Luckily, I got this free with my YR order.
I love Yves Rocher double-action eye make-up remover, but decided to try the one with Camomile too. I wa really dissaponted: it doesn't even take off eye shadow, not to speak about mascara. And you have to rub it with cotton pad, all this makes this product one of the worst.
This product is awesome. It is non-oily and a liquid (not a gel/cream). It removes eye makeup really well, even mascara (although I do not use waterproof mascara). One of my favorite eye makeup removers!
this left a greasy after feel it still left me with black smudges.
Aren't we all different! This is my favorite eye make-up remover, I have been using this for several years, have tried others but always come back to this. It easily removes all of my mascara, I do not wear waterproof, but I do wear a lot of mascara. I highly recommend this product.
This is a liquid, non-oily eye makeup remover. I thought this could be an interesting item as I prefer liquid over gel/cream as far as this type of product is concerned. The problem is; it doesn't remove any makeup! I had to rub a lot for it to take off eyeliner and it never managed to completely remove my mascara. A good eye makeup remover shouldn't require any rubbing. This product is not worth buying. I gave it a 2 because at least it didn't irritate my eyes.