WRITE A REVIEW
78% would repurchase
Package Quality: 4.2
Filter by skin/hair/eye
Filter by age
on 9/15/2009 7:17:00 AM
More reviews by jawbreaker
Skin: Other, Fair, Not Sure
Hair: Brunette, Other, Other
This is a very pretty, very dark brown shade that looks realistic with dimension and is shinny. Note: This is NOT black! It is a very dark brown shade and for those who don't have dark hair or don't have very dark hair, I could see where they could think this is maybe black, but it is not. My normal hair color is dark brown/almost black and this is very close to it. I decided to try NI after coloring my hair with Clairol Perfect 10 Dark Brown because I really didn't need a perm. hair color and wanted to try a demi perm hair color instead. Prior to using this, the darkest brown DIY haircolor I have found was Perfect 10 Dark Brown (again, not black, it is just a very dark brown) and the Perfect 10 matched my natural hair color almost perfectly and myself nor my husband could even see roots even months using it (and even my mom couldnt' tell I colored my hair)...but I since I only have a few gray hairs and just wanted something to help liven up my natural color (since I've turned 31, I've noticed my hair isn't as vibrant as it used to be), I thought I would try a demi and maybe didn't need the perm level Perfect 10 is. Back to NI in Nutmeg: I just used this the other day, so I will come back and report how it fades but so far, it is very pretty and natural looking. There was hardly a smell and it wasn't very runny or drippy. It was weird applying it to wet hair and at first, I had to be careful so I knew where I had applied the color, since the hair was already wet from the water. I do see a "slight" pull of redness in my hair but not like other DIY brands *cough, L'Oreal, see my reviews)* but the slight redness doesn't look like the fake "I've just colored my hair brown and have that fake redness to it" look that some brands (L'Oreal) give......it just looked like a little redness was there but it blended in with the dimension of the hair color. I do not like redness in my hair and my hair tends to pull red.....but like I said, this is *very slightly* there and looks like a natural part of the dimension of the dark brown hair color. Even though this is a very dark brown, it is probably very slightly lighter than Perfect 10's Dark Brown but not by much. When compairing it to Perfect 10's Dark Brown, I will say that when after first using Perfect 10's Dark Brown, it is a little too dark at first, a little "inky" even though it is not black and eventually fades after a few washings into not looking so dramatic....and with NI Dark Brown, I don't have that "inky/dramatic" look....which is why I will be curious to see how it fades (haven't washed my hair yet) over time because the results after just dying it look very nice and realistic, not "I just dyed my hair and need to wash is for a week before it looks OK" color. So far, I am very happy and my husband liked the color too, says it is very close to my natural shade which is what I wanted. I will say that the model they have on the box does not reflect the outcome of the shade....the hair color on her is at least a full shade lighter that these results, she's more of a level 5 medium brown shade and Nutmeg/Dark Brown is darker, a true level 4 dark brown shade, so don't go by the model on the box, go by the name and the color chart on the side of the box. I will update this in a few weeks to let you know how it fades, but so far, I really like this and it is a great very dark brown color (not black).UPDATE: It has been about 5 weeks since I've used this and I am still impressed. The color has faded as expected....not too fast, either. It hasn't faded into a weird redish/brown color either like a lot of DIY hairdyes do. I am still really impressed with this and will use this again.
7 out of 7 people found this review helpful.
on 9/14/2009 3:28:00 PM
More reviews by bela007
Skin: Normal, Fair, Not Sure
I color my hair every 4-6 weeks. For years I've been using a "natural" brand that I buy at Whole Foods for almost $18. I liked the color I got but the price was killing me. I decided to try Natural Instincts because it was on sale for $5.99 with a $2 instint coupon. What amazing results!! I just dyed my hair with it for the second month and I am even happier this time around than I was before. The color is rich and my hair is more managable and way shiner than it ever was with my other brand. The one thing I would like to mention however, is that the instructions for this hair color are a bit baffling to me. It says to apply to damp hair, I found that applying it to dry hair like other colors creates a deeper color. Additionally, the recommended time to leave the color in seems to be to short. I leave it in for 15 minutes after I finish coloring and it looks much more saturated but still doesn't stain my scalp. I really really like this product and will continue to use it. Did I mention it has no ammonia and smells great! A+
on 7/22/2009 12:58:00 AM
More reviews by VintageVixen87
Skin: Dry, Fair-Medium, Neutral
Hair: Blond, Wavy, Fine
I've been going from very light blonde (professionally done) back to brown due to not being able to afford the $140 salon visits anymore. I wanted to go a bit darker than my natural color, which is a light brown/dark mousey blonde. I started with a Wella medium golden brown color to be safe. Of course it faded to a medium golden blonde. Ick. I decided instead of risking dying it again I would put a non-permanent color on it. Since this one lacked some of the nasty chemicals I decided it would be a good one to go with. I wanted the color to stay so I went for a dark natural brown. Dying was easy. I like Clairol's easy mixing. No measuring involved, it's nice. The only issue I had was that the bottle of conditioner that came with it was not made correctly. The bottle was literally sideways and the top of it wasn't sealed. Odd. Luckily I had another bottle from my Shine Happy experiment. Anyway, since my hair was all one color I put this on all of my hair at once. When I washed it out I was a little scared of the color I saw, it looked black. I dried it right away and it still looked blackish. Well, the ends did. My natural hair at the roots took to the color much differently. It actually brought out more red tones, so my roots are lighter and a little reddish. I decided I did like the color after looking at it and remembered it'd wash out a bit. One thing I did LOVE was how healthy, good smelling, and full my hair was after using this and the conditioner. It looked amazing! 24 hours later, as recommended to wait, I washed my hair. I shampooed it twice and conditioned it. I noticed the water in the tub was brownish which made me happy because I thought it would lighten up a bit. It was still super dark looking wet, obviously. I put in some wave spray and let my hair air dry. After it was 90% dry I inspected it carefully. The color had nicely evened out and was a beautiful shade of dark brown with a reddish shine. I think my hair turned it brassy but it sure doesn't look bad. My roots look more tamed and blend in with the rest of my hair a bit better. I will totally buy this product again in this shade. Next time I think I'll spend more time on my roots and go from there!
1 out of 1 people found this review helpful.
on 7/9/2009 1:11:00 AM
More reviews by livelaughlove181
Age: 18 & Under
Skin: Very Oily, Olive, Not Sure
I used to have naturally very dark brown hair, almost black. But when I started getting highlights and as I got older, it began to get lighter. Still a dark brown, but the warm coloring made it a little blondish. So I used this product and LOVED IT. It worked amazing, smelled great, and left my hair very soft and shiny. The color has also lasted very well without fading. I would definitely buy this again, and plan on buying it again when this fades!
3 out of 3 people found this review helpful.
on 4/15/2009 3:09:00 PM
More reviews by Tina68
Skin: Acne-prone, Other, Not Sure
Hair: Black, Curly, Coarse
My review is for the shade Nutmeg. I have naturally very dark hair, almost black and Nutmeg was a good shade for me. My hair turned out dark brown, but in the sunlight it had a reddish-brown tinge to it that I liked alot. I have been using Colour Spa for several years and actually prefer it to Natural Instincts. But those living in Canada know that finding Colour Spa is a challenge since it is not widely carried anymore. Hence why I used Natural Instincts...it is easily available at SDM. I like the formula of Natural Instincts a lot. It is thick and not as runny as Colour Spa. Plus, the application time is a lot less, it is easier to mix and you get a 6-week supply of conditioner. While Nutmeg was as dark as I had anticipated, it did not cover my gray very well. In fact, I had grays peaking out less than a week after colouring and I colour to cover the gray. I may need to leave the colour on longer than the recommended 10 minutes next time. I also noticed that my hair was not as shiny or soft after using this, especially where my hair is parted it looked dull and kind of frizzy.I am returning to Colour Spa in the meantime and stocking up on it. But if I'm ever in a pinch, I would use Natural Instincts again.
2 out of 2 people found this review helpful.
on 2/23/2009 1:38:00 PM
More reviews by mooshrimp
Hair: Brunette, Curly, Medium
Awhile ago I decided to go red in a box. It looked good, but left my hair super damaged from the lightening and once the color faded I had a hideous orangey color left over. In an act of desperation I decided to try this because supposedly it is non-damaging and would eliminate the gross brassiness from my last color. When I first washed it out my hair looked jet black and I was panicking a little, but after I let it air dry I realized I had this perfect shiny gorgeous dark brown. No more red either! I was thrilled and so many people noticed how much better my hair looked. While my hair wasn't in BETTER condition after using (it is still a dye), it didn't seem to damage it at all. I highly recommend this stuff!
on 1/12/2009 6:13:00 PM
More reviews by suzanneb
Skin: Very Dry, Fair, Cool
Hair: Brunette, Wavy, Fine
Nutmeg keeps my hair looking shiny and fab in between colorings, it never leaves my hair crunchy or dry and my hair has a lot of bounce and volume after I use it, my natural color is dark neutral brown, this color has a touch of warmth but is never red which I avoid like crazy. Will forever buy this shade.Oct 29, 2013: came full circle, back to using Nutmeg again, hair looks shiny and rich, not luxurious like Mocha but that will be my next color.Nov 4, 2013: retouched the red parts that I missed and when I was done I used a spray bottle to distribute everything, the color came out even, all one color, no fading parts or red parts, a true miracle. The color looks mega dark brown, one step below black, if black is a level 1, this color is a level 2, no red, warm or gold tones, neutral leaning towards ash, same as my natural color.Dec 15, 2013: had to re color today, hair got really red again.
on 10/27/2008 2:51:00 PM
More reviews by rebchandler
Skin: Oily, Medium, Not Sure
Figured I'd go ahead and review this product, since I have used it hundreds (literally) of times! I love to color my hair often...and in doing so, have had many uneven and just plain bad hair colors. This is a product I always turn to to fix my mistakes! I've probably been using this over the last 15 years. My hair is naturally very dark brown (although I haven't seen my "natural" color in forever). Anyway, anytime I want to return to my color without harming my overprocessed hair any further, I turn to Natural Instincts. It doesn't matter what damage or color I've put on my hair, Natural Instincts Nutmeg always returns it to a dark, shiny healthy looking brown. And, it usually lasts until I decide to do something different to my hair! In fact, even though this is a sem-permanant color...the fading is very minimal on me & I don't think I've ever seen it fade completely out. I know this review is for Nutmeg...but I've also used Rosewood (deep reddish brown), Cinnaberry (medium reddish brown) and some of the blonde shades as toner when I've bleached my hair. I've always been happy with all the shades I've used, although Nutmeg does seem to give me the most even color (probably because it is easiest to dye all of your hair dark). I will say that when they changed the packaging a few years back...they put a picture of a girl on the front & her hair looks more dark golden brown. Do not be mistaken...this color comes out truly dark brown (without being black). I can see where someone who is used to a lighter hair color would mistake this for black when they first see it on their hair! But it is not, it is very true to its decription of Dark Neutral Brown. Anyway, I highly recommend this to anyone and it is definitely a HG for me!
6 out of 6 people found this review helpful.
on 10/5/2008 5:50:00 PM
More reviews by riffrandal
Skin: Very Oily, Other, Not Sure
Hair: Brown, Other, Other
Beautiful dark brown, high shine, rich shade. I have very fair skin and hazel eyes and this color is perfect on me. Not too dark, but just right. I love this color because it is neutral without being bland. I was afraid of the color turning out too dark after reading some of the reviews here, so I followed the instructions exactly, leaving it on my roots for 5 minutes, then blending through the rest of my hair and leaving on for an additional 5 minutes. I might leave it on a bit longer next time as it does not appear quite as dark as the color my haircolorist used last time (she used a professional non-permanent hair color in a similar shade but left it on for at least 20 minutes). I do not have greys so I can't say if it covers grey or not. I normally have my hair professionally hightlighted every 3 months, but my very fine hair was starting to display a lot of damage. Last time I went in for my haircolor appointment my hairstylist recommended a non-permanent hair color to help my hair recover from past damage. I was amazed at how healthy my hair looked and felt. Clairol Natural Instincts leaves me with the exact same healthy, shiny look and feel. I'm curious to see if it lasts as long as the professional shade.
3 out of 4 people found this review helpful.
on 7/4/2008 8:18:00 PM
More reviews by rosiel776
Age: 56 & Over
Skin: Other, Other, Not Sure
Hair: Other, Other, Other
i wanted DARK BROWN hair, however, it turned out JET BLACK! what a nightmare.the only thing i liked about it was its ammonia free and didnt stink like the l'oreal productsnow i'm stuck with JET BLACK hair and would probably need to go to a salon and fix it.UGH
Popular Hair Color Products
Are you sure this product is discontinued?
daasfdsad, asdadasd, addasdasdas, asdasdasdasfsdfgdfs, fgdssdgfdgfg, gfgdgdfgdhfgj
Reviewer did not try the product Profanity/Vulgar language Advertising (Vendor promotion, iHerb Coupons etc.) Marketing campaign (BzzAgent, Influenster etc.)