oh gosh, i should have read the reviews before i went out and bought this eyeliner ! =[ welll at least it was buy1 get 1 free so it was ok.
yea it isnt really blackest black unless u reapply it multiple times.
but it find that this liquid eyeliner is easy for me to apply a really nice line. but not really worth my 10 dollars =/
but i like it though. so ill probably buy this product again.
Save your money and buy Jordana Fabuliner. It's the same thing!
I didn't like this because it wasn't pigmented enough, and didn't last very long through a night of clubbing at all. But the packaging was great and the felt tip was so easy to use! Eventually I lost it so I bought another liner.
Jordana Fabuliner was $1.99. I figured this would hold me over until I found my Revlon eye pen. It performed the same way, which was great. But upon finding my Revlon pen I realized they had identical packaging. Turns out they're both made in Italy. Swatched and there's no color difference, and they're both a tad watery. Seriously, same stuff.
I wasted almost ten dollars for a product worth $1.99. Granted, for the price and ease of use the Fabuliner is great and I do enjoy using it! But in no way is this ColorStay liner worth the price. Save your $$!
It's comparable to trying to line your eyes with a watercolor brush. On the bright side, it's fun to write on your skin with this, especially since it comes off so easily. Thumbs way, way down.
THE FORMULA SUCKS
i honestly don't think its the pen design becuase i can draw thin enough lines with the pen better than i can with a brush or felt tip. i got better control with the pen but the formula sucks! its way too thin and comes off with the tiniest bit of water. i usually wear it to school and when i come bkk, most of its gone >.> so its aint long lasting at all.
It stays on all day and doesn't smear. The only thing I do not like is that blackest black isn't as black as other liquid eyeliners. I'm not sure if its the color formula or if it's a pigmentation issue but it's just not all that dark. It barely comes out of the pen and maybe its my imagination but it seems that less is coming out of the pen. I am rarely disappointed in Revlon but this product is not good at all.
I was surprised by the bad reviews of this product. I find it super super easy to apply the liquid liner with this product. I usually hated, as in HATED(!), doing liquid liners since i dont have a steady hand and most liners have a flimsy/flexible brush. The brush/applicator for this liner is stiff and it kind of hurts which is why i took off one lippy. Other than that, it really does give a nice super thin line, it stays put, it dries quickly, and it really is a nice black. I dont see smudging but a bit of fading. I will probably repurchase!
this pen blows!! i bought this in blackest black...........blackest black my ass!!!! its gray..
tossed in the garbage
I hate this crap..it doesnt come out at all.I thought the other colorstay liquid liner was bad but this takes the cake and icing.I feel like Im going over the line too many times which make the line look mess and mess up a nice eye.Well not buy again and wish I could give this product a 0
i was very disappointed with this. i would compare the color payoff to painting with watercolors--it just didnt provide the intensity that im looking for in a liquid liner. the color came out sporatically, and the formula was very thin resulting in streakiness. i had to go back over the line a bunch of times to get it to show up, which took forever. and to think, the whole reason i liked the idea of it was that i thought it might be a faster way to apply liquid liner! not recommended.
Would not buy this again. This was dry and didn't work. It also came off at the sight of water. I couldn't rub my eyes without this coming off and it smudge too. I guess I'm off to find another waterproof eye liner.