This is a great eyeliner. I use it to tightline every day and it takes a few minutes to set, but once it does, it does not budge. It also doesn't drag on my skin like other cheap liners tend to do. The pigmentation is great and it's a very reasonable price. I'm still on my first one but have already purchased a backup. Wish I had discovered this sooner, it would have saved several panda eye disasters!
I stopped wearing eyeliner because all I remember of old eyeliners are the fact that it either runs or it just non-existent after an hour. This eyeliner stays on for hours and the pigment rarely wears off. If you even try to rub it off, you're not going to get all of the eyeliner off. It's a cheap eyeliner that really does what it says it does.
I wore this for years before upgrading to MAC fluidline. When I needed a liner for the gym I bought this to keep in my locker, not wanting to buy a second fluidline. After using fluidline and other pencil liners, I'm not in love with this eyeliner at all. It is *very* difficult to apply - it skips and tugs and goes on faintly unless you press kind of hard (which you don't want to do on your lashline). After a few months of me skipping the gym (woops), it is almost completely dry and won't apply, even after I've rubbed at it a bit.
the revlon colorstay is great, color pigmentation is nice, could be better, and the eyeliner doesn't smudge. or until 4 hours pass by. yes, about 4 hours. i like it though, i don't mind some touch ups throughout the day.
it's fantastic. only thing is when i wear it on my waterline it doesn't last too long. but it applies on so smoothly. buy it, you'll love it!
This particular color looked a little weird on me. The quality of the eyeliner is great, though. It doesn't glide on very smooth but it has good staying power.
The only eyeliner to have ever stayed on my waterline. I dont even have to apply a second layer or top it with black eyeshadow, it just stays. Not irritating and very black.
I've tried clinique, urban decay, dior, rimmel, stila, kajal, and so many more. This is the only one that stays. I do wipe my waterline with a q-tip first, really helps!
As an upper lip liner, it's okay..stays but isn't very creamy looking.
Packaging is standard, however the pencil will fall back into the tube if you dont hold the end firmly, so it could be better.
No matter how many eyeliners I use, no matter the brand or type, I always come back to this. It is by far my favorite eyeliner. It is the first eyeliner I ever used when I was 11 or 12. Since then, I've tried many high-end and drugstore eyeliners. Ad I've used liquid, cream, pencil, everything. But this eyeliner trumps everything in my book. It goes on very creamy but it doesn't smudge. For extra protection though, you can apply black eyeshadow over it, and it will stay in place all day. The sharpener is nice, but be careful not to break the eyeliner; I can't tell you how many times I've done that.
Anytime anyone has asked me about what eyeliner to use, I tell them this. And at $10, you can't go wrong!
This is a pretty good eyeliner.
I got this in a pack with the Grow Luscious Mascara so I'm not sure about the price. So I just put a 1.
I really like the dark black colour of this and the nice easy creamy texture.
Its easy to apply as well, I love the little mini sharpener on the end, its so cute and easy!
But this can smudge if you put pressure on it, but its not really bad!
I won't be buying this again though because I have other eyeliners that are better.
But I love the colour, texture, and easy application.
I think this product is pretty decent. It id pretty pigemented and stays pretty well on my asian oily eyelids. I took off a star because it doesn't glide on as well as my urban decay 24/7 eyeliner pencil. The packaging is all right, but it took time to get used to it. I didn't even know the sharpener was at the endxD Also, I broke the tip the first few times sharpeneing it, but now I'm better. So overall, I woudl recommend this product:)