This is great color and really long lasting.The only reason that I hate this is that while using the product it winds itself down so that the end is basically unreachable and this happens time and time again.Try the non- mechanical ones.
Repurchased this many times. Nice dark black lasts a good 8hrs. I use mainly for waterline and sometimes as a base for false eyelashes or liquid liner when I'm winging it. Always nice and smooth. Doesn't irritate eyes when waterlining.
I've purchased this eyeliner twice, mainly because it's the most stayput pencil eyeliner I could find that is not crazy expensive. However it's far from perfect. If I don't prime my lids, this stuff slides off as soon as I put it on. Even with priming it still flakes, migrates and fades after a few hours - not good! This eyeliner would only suit smoky looks in my opinion because it just can't keep a sharp line even though it's meant to be waterproof and smudgeproof, it's staying power isn't so great so I definitely don't recommend this for all day wear. It is also quite expensive being a drugstore product and not black enough so I will not repurchase this. I have discovered Bobbi Brown's long wear gel eyeliner and it is the most amazing eyeliner ever! Definitely going with that now on :)
My favorite liner for the inner rim. It does fade after awhile, but all liner in the inner rim will do that. It's a very dark black that's not especially creamy, which is what makes it good for the inner rim, but might make it not so great for just lining the eyes. I will continue to repurchase til something else is better, but so far UD, Nars, MAC, Tarte, and every other drugstore e/l have fallen short
I really wanted to like this. It's simple, it's slender, and very little fuss. Just twist up and use... my only concern is that, although it does have decent staying power (even on waterline), it irritates my eyes. Every time I use this eyeliner, at the end of the day, my eyes feel very dry and just red and uncomfortable. Not sure if that's just me, but I'd say if you have sensitive eyes, skip this one. =/
This is a great eyeliner. I use it to tightline every day and it takes a few minutes to set, but once it does, it does not budge. It also doesn't drag on my skin like other cheap liners tend to do. The pigmentation is great and it's a very reasonable price. I'm still on my first one but have already purchased a backup. Wish I had discovered this sooner, it would have saved several panda eye disasters!
I stopped wearing eyeliner because all I remember of old eyeliners are the fact that it either runs or it just non-existent after an hour. This eyeliner stays on for hours and the pigment rarely wears off. If you even try to rub it off, you're not going to get all of the eyeliner off. It's a cheap eyeliner that really does what it says it does.
I wore this for years before upgrading to MAC fluidline. When I needed a liner for the gym I bought this to keep in my locker, not wanting to buy a second fluidline. After using fluidline and other pencil liners, I'm not in love with this eyeliner at all. It is *very* difficult to apply - it skips and tugs and goes on faintly unless you press kind of hard (which you don't want to do on your lashline). After a few months of me skipping the gym (woops), it is almost completely dry and won't apply, even after I've rubbed at it a bit.
the revlon colorstay is great, color pigmentation is nice, could be better, and the eyeliner doesn't smudge. or until 4 hours pass by. yes, about 4 hours. i like it though, i don't mind some touch ups throughout the day.
it's fantastic. only thing is when i wear it on my waterline it doesn't last too long. but it applies on so smoothly. buy it, you'll love it!